I got Covid again, so lying down watching TV was my thing this week. Had a couple of things on backlog
Strange New Worlds Season 1
After hearing lots of hype about this show... it ended up being disappointing. It's not bad, in the slightest but it WAS compared favorable to Discovery and it's just different, not better. If that different is your jam, great.
Gorn episodes were fantastic. The first I ever got my oldest to sit through one episode of Star Trek. But... I had to look up what happened in the rest of episodes because they were very generic. Note that this was before Covid hit bad but I knew I had it before I got tested.
Anyway, I did enjoy how the spotlight is shared more fairly amongst the crew. One of the biggest flaws is how most epsiodes you could slot any character in, as they just stories first, and characters added later. SNW does not do that. Most of the stories are to enhance a character, as well as tell a story. They limited the overall season arc but still had something going on in the background
Discovery Season 4
I think they need to limit this show to 10 and bump SNW to 13. I think this season arc was okay but drives too much of the story. That being said, it does a way better job of creating factions like DS9 and shifting the political landscape around regularly... but it finishes with a unlikely but happy ending which is slightly unsatisfying.
Old conflicts from last season are back and still have significant ripples. This is the show where characters have the most growth. In fact, they have so much growth, they can even get a promotion. Before even spending seven years in the same position. People even... are promoted off the ship *shocked Pikachu face*
I was going to critise the bad guy in this season. Like, way to overdo it with the character being too obessesed trope.... but I watch Shazam with the kids yesterday and Billy Batson is more obsessed but just has less power. Otherwise it was fine. I like the punishment system for Booker
I liked the Arrival attempt but that should have been the focus, and more drawn out, with more details and less distractions like I can have something explode for 5 mins.... but seeing most people's reception to Arrival, I'm not suprised. They felt lovecraftian enough for a TV show
Which gets me to the point of why the shows are different. Discovery goes out of its way to try and get everyone working together. I swear to cow, I Burnham was in SNW, she would have found a way to reach an alliance with the Gorn. Which is ridiculous. SNW does not really give a shit about other cultures. It's just humans and maybe some Vulcan because Spock is popular... which is disappointing. Enterprise did more with the Aenar in one episode than SNW did in a season
Anway, both are enjoyable in their own way and not memorable and lackluster in others. I am giving them the same number but for very different reasons 8/10. (Yeah it's high. It's some of the best Star Trek has been for a while)