The Walking Dead: Season 9 (3/5)
Without a doubt, this has got to be one of the strangest seasons of TV I've ever seen (in terms of pacing).
I should elaborate, like a lot of people, I lost interest in The Walking Dead at some point during its run. For me, it was season 6, I struggled through season 7 and 8, and really stopped caring around then, and in a sense, had already started to stop caring by season 5. Borrowing season 9 was just a "sure, why not?" moment. So I should stress that like most seasons, this isn't a "proper watch" (in that it was on while I was working), but that said, well, this season is weird.
I'll start with what I actually quite liked, and that's the concept of it. If everything from season 1 to 6 (8 at the very latest) is post-apocalypse, season 9 is post-post-apocalypse. Walkers are still around, but individually are pushovers, and even herds can be easily dealt with when diverted. A lot of the season is focused with the emergence of what could genuinely be called new societies - towns/hubs connected by trade, mutual defence, fairs are held, a constitution is drafted, etc. We've gone from season 1, which starts a few weeks (or a month or so, I forget) from the start of the outbreak to what's functionally a new world. This is even reflected in the level of technology - at the start, the characters could burn through ammo easily, now, guns are rare, bows and spears are common, horses are used instead of cars, etc. There's nothing unique in this kind of regression in fiction, but it's certainly rare to see this kind of regression play out in real-time over the course of a series. Season 9 feels like a soft reboot in a number of ways, but if nothing else, its portrayal of the setting is kind of neat. You could even argue that this plays in thematically with the Whisperers - while I call BS on how they function (zombie masks hide them from walkers, but in season 1, the characters needed to drench themselves in blood to do that, and even then, it didn't always work), thematically, we can see the divide between civilization and savagery. I know those are loaded terms, but you've got the protagonists trying to make something good, while the Whisperers represent the worst of humanity. Hardly that deep, but I'll give credit where it's due.
Alright, enough positivity, time to get into what I didn't like. Like I said, this season is weird in terms of pacing. Episodes 1-5 take place 18 months after the end of season 8, then we jump into the future a whole 6 years, the timeframe of which lasts until the penultimate episode, then we jump again a few months into what feels like the start of a season, but is in fact the ending of this one. Less than one season, season 9 feels like one short season, one average season, and the episode of season 10 thrown in. What's even stranger is that the first five episodes still have Rick as the protagonist, but they're boring as fuck, and it's only after jetissioning Rick that the season starts to come into its own. After that, stuff happens, but it's really hit or miss as to which episodes are good or not. For instance, episode 14 is just a waste of time, whereas episode 15 is one of the best, most tragic episodes in the season overall. On one hand, there's a number of characters that are likable - Judith is a precious cinammon bun, prisoner!Neagan is fun, Lydia's a good character, but on the other, there's so much dull conversation going on elsewhere that it ends up dragging things down. Mainly at the start of the season, so things get better, but you've got to take the good with the bad.
So, yeah. I'll leave my ranking down below, but overall, while the season isn't the worst in the series, it's probably the messiest. Liked some stuff, disliked some stuff, really don't care enough to seek out season 10 anytime soon.
RANKINGS
9) Season 6
8) Season 9
7) Season 8
6) Season 5
5) Season 7
4) Season 2
3) Season 1
2) Season 4
1) Season 3