Shrek, 7/10
I hadn't seen this since I was a kid, but I remembered it pretty thoroughly because I saw it like 20 times then. It holds up. Obviously the animation's dated and the Smash Mouth soundtrack is more obtrusive than organic these days, but that's because of this movie's meme status, not because of the music itself. Shrek still stands out among typical animated movie protagonists, but especially at the time he was unlike anything ever seen before. The Disney renaissance era was dominated bu plucky, misunderstood but well-meaning underdogs who had to rise to the challenge and prove themselves in the world's eyes. Shrek, when he starts the movie, is selfish, misanthropic, devoid of ambition or greater desire, and his motivation is entirely out of self-interest. That's what makes his journey of self-discovery so engaging, and I picked up on a lot of interesting psychological elements I completely missed as a kid. For example, as much as Shrek paints himself enjoying his solitude, the moment he's given recognition by the wider populace (when fighting the knights) he embraces it wholeheartedly, suggesting he's not as solitary as he likes to think, or may even realize himself.
The movie balances contrasting styles really well. The pop songs and the orchestral score never tread on each other, and fit their respective scenes perfectly. For as much this movie was born, and is full of contempt and spite, the emotional core of the film is genuine and sincere, and the two elements also gel naturally. There's some genuinely great cinematography and framing here too. The biggest issue by far is the super lame forced third act conflict that comes out of a very selective, very convenient misunderstanding. It was lame then and it's lame now, and it easily docks at least 2 points off this movie. Otherwise there aren't really that many big issues. Not all of Donkey's jokes land, but it's natural to the character.
As much as this movie is memed, it is a genuine cultural touchstone that was made by people who really cared
Shrek 2, 8/10
Now this is how you do a sequel. This is very much a case of the sequel improving upon the first in every aspect without making it redundant: the animation's leagues better, the jokes are tighter, the editing's better, the story's more interesting and so on. It expands the universe in massive ways without falling into overindulgence, and builds upon the dynamic established in the first film. The new characters are fun and Fairy Godmother is a great villain. The themes of self-acceptance are expanded upon in interesting ways: Accepting yourself is great, but will others accept your self-acceptance? How much should you change for the ones you love? What is the price of true love?
While the first movie's climax is a bit underwhelming, the sequel has a proper, big action setpiece with old characters making a return and even reincorporating a joke from the first movie. Speaking of which, the line "You still look like a dashing stallion to me" was incredibly wholesome and sweet, and a perfect callback to an earlier line.
There's honestly not a lot I'd criticize. Donkey is perhaps playing a bit of a second fiddle, with Puss in Boots taking center stage as the sidekick, and as a result doesn't have much of an arc. But he still feels like an essential presence in the movie. So yeah, a really great sequel.