Suspiria (2018)
Remake of the Italian horror classic of the same name by Dario Argento from 1977, directed by Argento's countryman Luca Guadagnino, now better known for relationship dramas like Call Me By Your Name and Challengers.
The original 1977 version of Suspiria was a simplistic but heavily stylized gothic tale of an American ballerina joining a German dance school which turns out to be the base of operation for a sinister coven of witches. It was very straight forward but it had extremely striking visuals and an extremely striking soundtrack, in short it looked and felt unique, between the expressionist set designs, colourful lighting and funky prog rock soundtrack courtesy of Italian group Goblin.
Guadagnino reimagines Suspiria, originally just under 90 minutes, as a 2h 30m brick that, with all due respect, I think is best described as "boring and pretentious". There's a certain ambition there but it really wasn't paying off for me.
So, Guadagnino's Suspiria is set in a divided and austere 70's West Berlin overshadowed by the paranoia around the terrorist attacks of the RAF, a radical leftist guerilla group. Once again, we follow an American dancer played by Dakota Johnson as she joins a dance academy (although instead of ballet it's some hip, and dreadful, experimental style of dance utilized for ecstatic rituals) which belongs to a secret society of witches. Which this version never even treats as a mystery, it's very forward about the secret coven and has a subplot about its internal power struggles.
It's one of those things that, I will say, could theoretically have been good. when it was described to me I expected something like Andrzej Żuławski's bizarre horror classic Possession but Suspiria is instead a drawn out exercise in mildly uncomfortable drudgery and not in a purposeful way. I don't necessarily dislike the stark, brutalist and monochrome visual style but that, along with its meandering plot, drawn out scenes and droning Thom Yorke score makes for a movie that's just not pleasant or engaging to watch.
Suspiria tries to graft so many attempts at social commentary and drama onto the originals rather thin premise, none of which properly stick, no matter how much the movie insists on them. There's so many weird, half realized plot lines about division and radicalization and national guilt in there that I was waiting for to coalesce in a meaningful way but never felt they did. The movie more just slowly trickles along to a setpiece climax that, like all the movies other setpieces, has been done better and grittier in other movies and, like every potentially memorable scene in the movie, is undermined by a score that sounds like the musical equivalent of erectile dysfunction. Real talk? I don't care for Radiohead very much. The originals soundtrack is a tough act to follow, but Jesus...
Is there anything I liked about it? Yeah, Tilda Swinton's performance. She plays three characters in this, one of them an elderly German man and my god, I never could have told. Part of it is costume and make-up, sure, but the actual performance is just as convincing. Especially in the movie's very opening where she's opposite Chloe Moretz violently mangling the German language (To be fair, I think the character she was playing was supposed to be a non native speaker. At least I hope so) you'd never guess that that character is played by an englishwoman. If there's anything positive I took away from the movie it's this performance.
Because, frankly, there wasn't much else. I think Suspiria (2018) represents art house horror at its least enjoyable. Dour, overly long, throwing around themes but struggling to fit them into the actual narrative. Just an all around dry and plodding affair weighed down by almost every other scene going on for twice as long as it reasonably should. Long story short, I didn't like it.