I know we hate Kotaku but here is the rare opinion piece I agree with. Well, at least it accurately addresses some of the stuff I been trying to say and how I feel about modern gaming.
The Debate Over Silksong Points To A Growing Divide In Gaming
If you don't wanna click the link, basically what he's saying is that he finds it helpful to look at two mindsets in gaming: the folks that want a challenge and the folks that want a story and progress. He traces the former to arcades, where high scores and the social competitiveness of gaming was about performance and skill and there was no "finishing" a game. The latter traces to the rise of single player campaigns in games where you have some kind of a narrative and difficulty options and generally it was expected and desired to get to an actual "end."
So yeah it's another "difficulty in gaming" argument but also more specific and fair.
The article spoke to me because it made me realize how my tastes in gaming shift as I myself shifted between these two groups. I was an 80s arcade and NES kid so the social aspect of it and feeding quarters to machines was what gaming was to me- the first group, the OG git gud crowd.
Probably the first game I felt the need to get to the end was
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past. But then after that I kind of stopped gaming seriously for a long while. It as
Assassin's Creed 2 and
Uncharted 2 that drew me back in but that was all solo gaming at home and with stories so I re-entered gaming as the second group, the finish a story group.
Then I somehow got addicted to FromSoftware and was squarely in both groups for a bit but still they are single player games with sort of a story and finishing them was part of it. We talk about FromSoftware's impact on gaming all the time but really I think what it did was collapse these two groups and hence all the difficulty in gaming arguments.
I am now finding myself completely again in the second group- I buy a game, I wanna finish it. Hearing and reading people's experiences with Silksong makes me feel like I'm listening to cult members- "it's miserable that's why I love it! I can't believe how great this game is I wanted to throw my controller out the window during that one part where I had to fight a hundred dudes 10/10." As always I'm glad folks who enjoy this stuff are enjoying it, I'm gonna go back to saving my high school from the evil persona monsters...