How do you know that the room is sound-proof?
Or are you just basing this off hearsay, the kind of thing you reject as evidence?
I think the bit where they claim say they heard screaming is the sort of theatrical flourish that should set off anyone's bullshitometer.
That's stupid, but Roberts isn't a conservative either. He just sort of does whatever he thinks is pragmatic and rationalizes it after.
No, he is a conservative. He just declines to do the Republican party's onanistic fantasies for them when they're supposed to do it politically. Because whilst the Republicans say they just want by-the-book judges to stop liberal activist judges, what they actually want are their own activist judges to legislate from the bench.
It's just a measure of where the Republican Party has gone that they refuse to recognise him as one. What's actually happened is that Republican party has passed well beyond conservatism to some weird, radical, conspiracy-thery laded far-rightism, and they decided to erroneously hold on to the term "conservative" because they'd got used to it. So all these
actual conservatives are now RINOs, liberals, or whatever pejorative-du-jour to mask the fact that the party is collapsing into an abyss of crazy. As indicated by this grotesque post-election spasm (just in case the last four years weren't clear enough) where they've been actively trying to overrule a democratic election and argue that's somehow fine.
The problem people like you face is that you want to be reasonable, but on the other hand you don't want to accept that your much beloved party is now officially endorsing conspiracy theory and attempts to ignore democratic process. Caught in the cognitive dissonance, you're trying to steer a middle course, but a middle course between sanity and insanity is merely being half-insane.