Samtemdo8 said:
Well I am sorry but I do think CGI/Mo-capped has proven itself to be far superior to Make-Up. Especially make up for someone like Hellboy.
Davy Jones alone proves it and he was the best character in the movie.
So I have no idea what is this obsession with "physicalness" when it clearly looks cheap and inferior to the making something look literally alive through CGI.
Succesful CG characters are the exception rather than the rule. Davy Jones looked great because that movie had money -- this
Hellboy movie is likely to have a budget of at best 80 to 100 million. Also, Davy Jones wasn't the main character, meaning he had much less screen time than Hellboy will likely have in the new movie.
And even when a movie has a large (by today's standards) budget it can still go horribly wrong. Just look at the orcs in the
Hobbit trilogy.