So let me get this straight. You're pissed off about this reboot because 'you', person, don't like how they're reimagining the material, because 'you', obsessed fanboy/fangirl, think that MK and fantasy elements can't go without each other and will gripe endlessly until you get your way.Zeithri said:Well that's just it.
I loved that movie.
The new one will be nothing like that.
Goro? Will he be in it? Most likely not and if he is, he will most likely not be a Shokan but some psychotic freak..
So? Just because it's changed doesn't mean it's automatically bad. Jurassic Park is a good movie, and was one of my favorites growing up. But they sort of glossed over the discussions of the repercussions of the premise that were present in the book in favor of just letting things get worse and provide a good action movie. Is the movie any worse for it? Hell no!
I do film reviews on DeviantArt as a hobby, and every time I review a remake I try to see the original film first. And then, I give the remake two scores. The second score is how it compares to the original; the first score is a measure of how good the movie is on its own two legs. Why? Ultimately, the source material can really only heal or hurt the material in comparison to the movie.
The Uwe Boll Alone in the Dark is one of the worst video game adaptations of all time, mostly because it's a bad movie by itself with its shoddy editing, tensionless action scenes, uninteresting characters, and nonsensical story; the fact that there's almost no connection to the games themselves doesn't enter the equation until you consider the 'based on' bit.
Here's a question I think moviegoers like ourselves should ask at one point when we see these kinds of situations coming up:
"If you could go back in time and erase the source material so that this project would be a completely original work of cinema, what would you think of the movie then?"
If a movie is good by itself, I find I can forgive certain transgressions on the source material. If it's not, those transgressions ultimately make it worse for all.
(Oh, wait, I just wasted time typing that out; knowing how things are going to go, you're likely to come up with a two-sentence long rebuttal that make it increasingly obvious that your unforgiving nature about this remake is personal rather than logical. Okay, then, I'll save the work for you: disregard everything I said if you still think this remake is going to suck. If it doesn't, I told you so. If it does, you told me so, albeit for all the wrong reasons.)
As for my opinion on this? I'm supporting this effort, if only because it seems so damn awesome on its own.