Camaranth said:
So Escapists, has your own knowledge ever broken your willing suspension of disbelief?
It may not be a deal breaker, you can still enjoy the game, movie, show, book whatever but something just niggles at the back of your mind? Has something ever been so wrong that you just couldn't enjoy the subject matter anymore?
Recently I learned that the LD-50 (lethal dose for 50 percent of a population) for ionizing radiation for humans is 4 Gray or 400 rads. Playing Fallout 3 and my character is suffering radiation poisoning at 600rads. so either she is very very lucky or she is Dead!
Like I said not a deal breaker it just bothers me.
Facepalm.
If the LD-50 is the centre of a normal distribution then 600rads is well within the body of the population for survival but that isn't the last of it.
How about you read up on radiation poisoning a bit more, it is never that simple.
I worked as a radiographer and I saw patients regularly get up to 1 Gray to the torso in their treatment and they were expected to not show any symptoms. It's not just how many rads got through you but also:
-how much of the radiation is actually being absorbed
-what part of the body is absorbing it (eyes, skin, genital, bone marrow, brain, etc)
-what type of radiation (this is HUGELY important!)
-what rate is it being absorbed
-over what duration is it absorbed
-Was there a break in exposure
-what is the age/size/general-health of the subject
-Are they taking some treatment that might
-what shielding do they have (even a denim jacked makes a difference for alpha radiation)
-what the radiation emitted from outside, or inside the body from consumed particles
All these are far more important than the pure number of rads.
So you dropped your disbelief because you had worse than no-understanding of science, you had an incomplete understanding.