Most of the games that I've "Let's Play"'d on my YouTube channel I could be considered to be amazing at playing at... Games like Tales of Symphonia, Rayman 3, every US-released Kingdom Hearts games (especially the GBA Chain of Memories and all of the DS version), Jak 2, Rez/Child of Eden, the first Metroid Prime game, Odama, Virtua Quest, Beyblade VForce: Ultimate Blader Jam, Lemmings, Star Fox: Assault, and Pokemon Emerald end up becoming games that I'm amazingly good at because I spent so much time playing them, studying them, and at times even writing pencil-driven spreadsheets like I'm playing pseudo-DnD without the dice... Then again, this does not include all of the time that I've completed them from start to finish, so there's that...
With that said, the separation from being amazing and just being good mostly comes from how much "immersion" ends up going into playing any game in particular... Anyone can have their favorite/least favorite moments in any particular video game, but it's one thing to say that it's hard, another thing to say that it's hard if you do or don't do X, and another thing to start ranking everything in details-worth of reasoning... Also, even if one claims yo be amazing at a particular game, for example, there can still be new tricks to learn, new ways of experiencing the same shit, and new comparisons to be made that it ends up becoming a pseudo-allegory for life itself...
Now, if we were referring to speedrunning, then I ain't shit... except in Kingdom Hearts, but that was an easy trochievement, anyway...
With that said, the separation from being amazing and just being good mostly comes from how much "immersion" ends up going into playing any game in particular... Anyone can have their favorite/least favorite moments in any particular video game, but it's one thing to say that it's hard, another thing to say that it's hard if you do or don't do X, and another thing to start ranking everything in details-worth of reasoning... Also, even if one claims yo be amazing at a particular game, for example, there can still be new tricks to learn, new ways of experiencing the same shit, and new comparisons to be made that it ends up becoming a pseudo-allegory for life itself...
Now, if we were referring to speedrunning, then I ain't shit... except in Kingdom Hearts, but that was an easy trochievement, anyway...