Vykrel said:
i know it is popular to hate on it, but Mass Effect 3's ending really was atrocious. ill never understand why so many people fail to see that. it negates everything the player has accomplished over the three games, and the Star Child's logic is completely ridiculous.
"i have to use my synthetics to kill you organics so that you arent killed by your own synthetics". this logic is made even more unsound by the fact you are can bring peace among the Quarian and the Geth after less than a friggin year.
really, just a god awful ending. i remember starting a second playthrough of ME2 the day after i beat it, but i still havent been able to bring myself to revisit the series, now that i have seen how it ends. it was all just so pointless. nothing mattered.
First of all: I agree that the ending is bad. but this failure to understand the logic behind the star child is stupid.
Synthetics have zero need for organic life. So if we make AI, and then, inevitably, war with them, what will they do? They will wipe out all the people. But, since they don't want to do this again, they will continue to wipe out any new organic people who might show back up.
Reapers, on the other hand, show up and kill all advanced life, including the synthetics. They then leave. So when they did their thing on the protheans, they didn't destroy humans, asari, krogans, etc who were all in their infancy. The reapers job is to let life grow without malicious AI(I understand the irony) coming in and destroying all life.
This is still stupid with the ability to make peace with the geth, and the general theme of the game being that AI and organics can live in peace. (see EDI and Joker) but it's not completely illogical.