Battlefield 4: China Rising Gets Banned in China

Recommended Videos

xPixelatedx

New member
Jan 19, 2011
1,315
0
0
EA's Battlefield 4: China Rising involves a war between American protectors of freedom and a manipulative Chinese admiral.
No it isn't, its about several giant, empty flat maps made just for snipers and vehicles. I don't recall it even having anything to do with china. Oh, I'm sure that's where it's supposed to be, but honestly it could be almost anywhere it's so ambiguous and lazily designed.
 

Coreless

New member
Aug 19, 2011
298
0
0
Fireprufe15 said:
I have to wonder if America would also get upset if they were the antagonist. With all the effort they put into being real evil, I can't help but think they would see it as a compliment.
Lol yea America is sooooooo evil soooo terrible, I guess we should have let the world fall under the treads of Nazi Germany and Japan during WWII. Look at all that evil $37 Billion we give out in foreign aid each year, maybe we should just end it all because its all clearly blood money. Perhaps we should end all our trade agreements with many countries as well because clearly the more moral world wouldn't want to be involved with such an evil country.
 

RicoADF

Welcome back Commander
Jun 2, 2009
3,146
0
0
Waaghpowa said:
All these people telling China to "lighten up". What do you think would happen if someone made a game portraying America in the same way China was in Battlefield? The Right wing in America would be throwing a shit fit about FREEDOM! and try to ban it.

It's easy to say "Lighten up" when your country is the one being portrayed as the heroic "protectors of freedom". Fictional or not.

Hypocrisy all around, not just China.
That reminds me of an Extra Credits episode, James show a patriotic American "America's Army" which he obviously endorsed and said everyone should play, but when shown a game where the roles were reversed (another nation as the good guys and America as bad) his tune changed to wanting to have it censored/banned. The US republicans made a big fuss with Medal of Honor (2010) and that was only due to the enemies being playable Taliban, god help any game that has a campaign from their side.
 

kasperbbs

New member
Dec 27, 2009
1,855
0
0
I really can't blame them. I'm curious to see how would the US react if someone made a big budget game with them as the bad guys and with the Russians, Chinese and whatnot coming to the rescue of the world.
 

Thaluikhain

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 16, 2010
20,140
4,508
118
Coreless said:
Lol yea America is sooooooo evil soooo terrible, I guess we should have let the world fall under the treads of Nazi Germany and Japan during WWII.
Firstly, that was 70 years ago, and secondly, the US wasn't too concerned about the expansion of Germany and Japan until they declared war on it.
 

MCerberus

New member
Jun 26, 2013
1,168
0
0
To be fair a reasonable plot line involving the two countries going to war would not exactly be fun. You see, there would be an event or skirmish involving either the Republic of China or an accident in the dick-measuring territorial waters contest going on. This would be followed by a runup and positioning where the allies of both nations destabilize due to the withdrawal of military forces and support and them simultaneously being let "off the chain".

Then the whole world wets their pants when they remember "oh wait this thing can kill all of us." Also a massive shock to the economy that will spin... well everyone... into a deep economic depression I don't think we have words for.


Actually nevermind. Writing in this setting has a lot more potential than the "this eagle is crying. Let's shoot us some foreigners because they're different."
 

karloss01

New member
Jul 5, 2009
991
0
0
Hey China, grow a pair! Russia has been the villain punching bag for a while now and to an extent us British as well. we wouldn't be bitching if you made a game where the US goes ape shit and invades the world and you come and save the day; we'd only care if it was crap. :D
 

MCerberus

New member
Jun 26, 2013
1,168
0
0
karloss01 said:
Hey China, grow a pair! Russia has been the villain punching bag for a while now and to an extent us British as well. we wouldn't be bitching if you made a game where the US goes ape shit and invades the world and you come and save the day; we'd only care if it was crap. :D
You are not familiar with the American right-wing are you?
 

Kenbo Slice

Deep In The Willow
Jun 7, 2010
2,706
0
41
Gender
Male
ClockworkUniverse said:
On the one hand, I'm against censorship.

On the other hand, that developers still make xenophobic shit like this in 2013 is pretty disgusting.
But it's not Xenophobic. They're not saying "all of China is bad hurr durr." The bad guy is a ROGUE Chinese General. He has nothing to do with China as a whole. Maybe play the story or at least read the plot synopsis before you make these wild claims?
 

Adam Jensen_v1legacy

I never asked for this
Sep 8, 2011
6,647
0
0
Kenbo Slice said:
ClockworkUniverse said:
On the one hand, I'm against censorship.

On the other hand, that developers still make xenophobic shit like this in 2013 is pretty disgusting.
But it's not Xenophobic. They're not saying "all of China is bad hurr durr." The bad guy is a ROGUE Chinese General. He has nothing to do with China as a whole. Maybe play the story or at least read the plot synopsis before you make these wild claims?
But it's still a rogue Chinese general. It could never happen to an American general.

Well, it did in Modern Warfare 2. But the real bad guys were still Russians and the plot continued from CoD4 which was also about bad Russians.
 

Abomination

New member
Dec 17, 2012
2,939
0
0
kasperbbs said:
I really can't blame them. I'm curious to see how would the US react if someone made a big budget game with them as the bad guys and with the Russians, Chinese and whatnot coming to the rescue of the world.
It wouldn't sell very well, that's what would happen.

But the US wouldn't censor it.

I actually don't give a shit about what the morality police of China get up to these days. If they ban it, fine. Good. Maybe less developers will care about trying to get involved in the Chinese market. Less time they spend trying to water down their stories so they don't upset the Chinese by implying they have draconian censorship and propaganda legislation the less game companies will have to worry about their draconian censorship and propaganda legislation.
 

Auron

New member
Mar 28, 2009
530
0
0
amaranth_dru said:
(except maybe the game America's Army, which doesn't take sides as far as I'm aware, nor is it propagandistic).
Actually America's Army is a recruiting tool and you're never playing the Arabs(It was arabs I think.), the other games are mostly neutral though.


Waaghpowa said:
All these people telling China to "lighten up". What do you think would happen if someone made a game portraying America in the same way China was in Battlefield? The Right wing in America would be throwing a shit fit about FREEDOM! and try to ban it.

It's easy to say "Lighten up" when your country is the one being portrayed as the heroic "protectors of freedom". Fictional or not.

Hypocrisy all around, not just China.
Er... Spec Ops the line did fine, the latest Splinter Cell has US-sanctioned intelligence agents constantly breaking international laws, geneva convention included, torturing prisioners for quick intel and even breaking into Guantanamo to steal intelligence from the US itself. GTA paints highly corrupt US government officials as a common thing, the aforementioned Fallout has the remnants of the US government trying to kill every single survivor so they can repopulate the US with pure rad free "civilized" individuals and on that note Marvel comics has been painting the US government in a specially bad light for about a decade now, all of these are doing perfectly fine and there's no sign of censorship at all. There's a few idiots complaining about violence but that's a different issue altogether.

All that said, Has anyone actually played Battlefield's campaign? I still haven't started bf3's. Also China was a faction in BF2 and C&C Generals a decade ago and I don't remember this kind of stupidity(Then again they've probably banned Generals at least.) I've heard China is actually not the villain but some old guard guy who thinks they should take over the world, it's a cliche but I don't see how it's "omfg offensive." If anything it's a sign they should have kept the Battlefield fluff to the little text boxes before each map describing the battle's background but I don't see the grounds for censorship, we don't censor bad stories.
 

BarbaricGoose

New member
May 25, 2010
795
0
0
Sseth said:
I don't blame them at all. All of those call of poopy and battleshit games do is pander to american patriotic ego, and I don't even think it's far fetched to say that these companies receive something on the side for making their games more patriotic and painting the US's rivals in a bad light.

They're better off without it anyway. Military macho jerk off material really needs to get de-throned this generation or I'm going to go berserk.
You know, when you say stuff like "Military macho jerk off material" in reference to CoD, you're kind of insulting EVERYONE who plays CoD. I mean... you realize that, right?

I don't see why people feel the need to make up awful, awful puns like "Call of poopy" and "Battleshit." Can't I just enjoy my CoD and Battlefield without constantly being made to feel like I'm some asshole? I mean, I don't make up names and insult the games you enjoy. Why ya gotta do it to me?

Other than having the audacity to casually enjoy a game you seem to want to vilify for some inane reason, what did I ever do to deserve this?
 

ClockworkUniverse

New member
Nov 15, 2012
233
0
0
Kenbo Slice said:
ClockworkUniverse said:
On the one hand, I'm against censorship.

On the other hand, that developers still make xenophobic shit like this in 2013 is pretty disgusting.
But it's not Xenophobic. They're not saying "all of China is bad hurr durr." The bad guy is a ROGUE Chinese General. He has nothing to do with China as a whole. Maybe play the story or at least read the plot synopsis before you make these wild claims?
Okay, that actaully is somewhat better, and that's my mistake. In that case, the game's plot is at the very least less problematic than I thought. However, I still feel justified in my more general concerns regarding xenophobia in modern military games, when we're getting stuff like the COD game about how all of South America suddenly turns into an evil hivemind because reasons.
Res Plus said:
ClockworkUniverse said:
On the one hand, I'm against censorship.

On the other hand, that developers still make xenophobic shit like this in 2013 is pretty disgusting.
Yeah, there should be no negative portrayals of anything in any game, ever (other than middle class white people, they are all wankers and should be portrayed negatively at all times).
Sure is fun to pretend people who disagree with you are saying completely stupid things so you can just dismiss them. Much easier than actually reading and thinking.

I have nothing against characters of any given ethnicity being used as villains. It's just when they're villains because of the ethnicity itself that things get problematic. If the other post I quoted is accurate, this game's story is far less of an issue than I thought, and I've perhaps been trained to expect the worst by other media (though I would still argue that the title is deliberately provocative at best).
 

Racecarlock

New member
Jul 10, 2010
2,497
0
0
How the hell are you supposed to prove you're not bad guys when you're censoring opposing speech? That's not a good sign.
 

Aeshi

New member
Dec 22, 2009
2,640
0
0
amaranth_dru said:
Video game with a fictional plot about a rogue military leader who happens to be Chinese starting a war.
To be fair, "Rogue military leader" is the Antagonist version of "I'm not racist, but..."
 

bluegate

Elite Member
Legacy
Dec 28, 2010
2,751
1,347
118
Good for China that they are standing up against this, it is high time that people start paying more attention to hidden propaganda in video games and its effect on the populous.

Demonizing a certain group of people for years on end in fiction has a negative effect on the general opinion of people on this group.

It was already talked about in this thread but people ought to check this video;

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UP4_bMhZ4gA&feature=youtube_gdata_player
 

ThunderCavalier

New member
Nov 21, 2009
1,475
0
0
Am I the only one that finds it funny that, of all the things that Battlefield is getting headlines for, it's because of its Single Player?

No offense to anyone that enjoys the Battlefield Single Player campaign... but it's certainly nothing to write home about. Honestly speaking, you bought the game only for its awesome Multiplayer.

That being said, it's China. Of course anything that portrays them in a negative light will get their ire.

On the other hand, I do agree with people in that this whole patriotic wankfest is getting a bit tired. Wouldn't mind another Spec-Ops The Line to show up.
 

Tomeran

New member
Nov 17, 2011
156
0
0
Its China. They'll censor the living shite out of anything that doesnt kiss their behinds.

As for perspective, it doesnt matter. Its wrong no matter where it happens. It doesnt matter that the US is the horribly overdone patriotic hero. If they were the villains and the game would somehow the censored there, it would still be wrong. Doesnt matter who's doing it, its still wrong. I dont think the US or even Russia would do it, even if things could definetly be in a better shape in both those countries, but there would obviously be hardcore rightwing nutcases thinking it would "damage national integrity and morale" or whatever. But those are the same kind of crazy people that think that if you arent wearing a T-shirt with your nations colours you're a traitor. The only thing this shows is that these people have a tad more to say about things in China, and that they like to try and keep their population brainwashed, NK-style.

A little scary when you think about how many people that involves.
 

rasputin0009

New member
Feb 12, 2013
560
0
0
I'd censor the single player story, too. Damn, that was terrible. If they just brought back Bad Company, which they won't, they'd have something respectable. The Expendables is popular right now and Bad Company meets that niche so WHY THE FUCK WOULD THEY DO THE SAME THING AS THEIR MAIN COMPETITOR? Goddamn EA/DICE, it doesn't need to be country vs. country. It could be simply mercenaries vs. mercenaries. It's not like there's an actual canon to protect or be faithful to.

Oh right, China as villains. Umm, well White House Down is a fresh movie that didn't use xenophobia as a plot/emotional device while Olympus Has Fallen did. Both are the exact same movie except White House Down is amazing (minus the flag-waving part of the ending) and Olympus Has Fallen is pretty shit (every second scene was jerking off into the American flag). That's only one example of how boring it is to use common bullshit beliefs for stories. While yes, it can be entertaining to explore fantastical real-world conflicts, it's really hard to pull off anything but a superfluous shell of a plot.