Biggest Game Disappointments

Recommended Videos

worldruler8

New member
Aug 3, 2010
216
0
0
ChupathingyX said:
worldruler8 said:
Spore. Just spore...if you saw the GDC 2005 demo, you know exactly what I am talking about.
You mean that glorious 35 minute demonstration?

*sigh* what could have been...
That was just the video, there is a 60 minute one that includes Will Wright talking (out of his ass). Not all of it is on the video (particularly the beginning), but even then, it is pretty interesting.
 

nimbylive

New member
Apr 15, 2009
55
0
0
I will second (or third) Final Fantasy 13. I have played most of the series prior and loved 12, but 13 was just garbage that I could not force myself to play through.

I would like to add a terrible disappointment:

Too Human. This was an early X360 game that was boring and a little simplistic. It was in production since the PS1 days and when it did finally come out, it was just a throw away action game.
 

AyaReiko

New member
Aug 9, 2008
354
0
0
Let's see...

Spore. Officially when EA decided its userbase consisted entirely of drooling retards.
Master of Orion 3. Made by a douchebag who didn't know what he was doing, and it shows.

And...

RAGE. The point I lost faith in id Software. Graphics were nowhere near id what was hyping them to be (even after all the patches). Gameplay felt like something from at least 6 years ago. Only thing rage-inducing was the ending, most of the rest of it sucked.
 

Epidemiix

Custom Title Yay!
Jan 3, 2012
124
0
0
nimbylive said:
Too Human. This was an early X360 game that was boring and a little simplistic. It was in production since the PS1 days and when it did finally come out, it was just a throw away action game.
I never heard of the game in development, but I saw it when it came out and pretty much said "wow what an interesting concept!".

Couple hours later it was pretty much "why am I still playing?" It wasn't really that bad overall....but the parts that were bad really broke the game completely and made me not want to play.,
 

wooty

Vi Britannia
Aug 1, 2009
4,252
0
0
I would say the ending to ME3, but we all know by now that it wasnt the end, so mute point.

For me, Gears 3's ending was crap and Halo 3's ending was crap. There was so much hype and then it just.....nothing happened, even the final "battles" were shallow and easy.

They easilly trump ME3 by a country lightyear.
 

Epidemiix

Custom Title Yay!
Jan 3, 2012
124
0
0
wooty said:
I would say the ending to ME3, but we all know by now that it wasnt the end, so mute point.

For me, Gears 3's ending was crap and Halo 3's ending was crap. There was so much hype and then it just.....nothing happened, even the final "battles" were shallow and easy.

They easilly trump ME3 by a country lightyear.
I think problem with Reach's ending in my opinion was the audience (most of them.....maybe not) knew that what the ending of the game was already going to be best on the story of Reach.

I thought Gears 3 ending was good all things considered(Oh no FLAK ARGHGHGGH).
 

wooty

Vi Britannia
Aug 1, 2009
4,252
0
0
Epidemiix said:
wooty said:
I would say the ending to ME3, but we all know by now that it wasnt the end, so mute point.

For me, Gears 3's ending was crap and Halo 3's ending was crap. There was so much hype and then it just.....nothing happened, even the final "battles" were shallow and easy.

They easilly trump ME3 by a country lightyear.
I think problem with Reach's ending in my opinion was the audience (most of them.....maybe not) knew that what the ending of the game was already going to be best on the story of Reach.
Reach I actually did like, the whole thing seemed more complete and a lot less rushed. Halo 3 however...........the whole game just didn't even graze the hype the thing generated.
 

Epidemiix

Custom Title Yay!
Jan 3, 2012
124
0
0
wooty said:
Epidemiix said:
wooty said:
I would say the ending to ME3, but we all know by now that it wasnt the end, so mute point.

For me, Gears 3's ending was crap and Halo 3's ending was crap. There was so much hype and then it just.....nothing happened, even the final "battles" were shallow and easy.

They easilly trump ME3 by a country lightyear.
I think problem with Reach's ending in my opinion was the audience (most of them.....maybe not) knew that what the ending of the game was already going to be best on the story of Reach.
Reach I actually did like, the whole thing seemed more complete and a lot less rushed. Halo 3 however...........the whole game just didn't even graze the hype the thing generated.
I'll take your word for it! I didn't have it when it came out and I wasn't big into the new 360 at the time.
 

Metaphysic

New member
Jul 1, 2011
77
0
0
Kingdoms of Amalur.

A bunch of really pretty scenery and fun combat, but a terrible loot system, mediocre story and an extraordinarily bland world killed it for me.
 

LongDanzi

New member
Nov 15, 2011
28
0
0
brink it was a good idea but not a whole lot to offer. not many modes other than play story and.... play story with other people who I don't know.
 

BloatedGuppy

New member
Feb 3, 2010
9,569
0
0
Anthraxus said:
New Vegas was the best mainstream RPG to come out in years. They showed Bethesda how an open world rpg should be done.
I'm actually quite a fan of Obsidian and have talked them up at numerous intervals, but I can't really understand the New Vegas affection. It felt like the world's biggest expansion pack for FO3. There was literally zero difference for me, aside from a slightly shittier atmosphere and a significantly improved sniping system.

MOTB is Obsidian's high watermark.
 

Smeatza

New member
Dec 12, 2011
932
0
0
Final Fantasy 12
It's Final Fantasy with a crappy story and incredibly unappealing characters. I've not even looked at the series since.

BloatedGuppy said:
Anthraxus said:
New Vegas was the best mainstream RPG to come out in years. They showed Bethesda how an open world rpg should be done.
I'm actually quite a fan of Obsidian and have talked them up at numerous intervals, but I can't really understand the New Vegas affection. It felt like the world's biggest expansion pack for FO3. There was literally zero difference for me, aside from a slightly shittier atmosphere and a significantly improved sniping system.

MOTB is Obsidian's high watermark.
Well for me, it was what FO3 should have been. They were both similar (especially in looks and mechanics) but there was no room to role play at all in FO3. Like all of Bethesda's games that try to be non-linear you can clearly tell which story path is the "correct" one that the developers put the most effort into, the rest tend to but full of plot holes and lack of choices.
 

Simonoly

New member
Oct 17, 2011
352
0
0
Too many, but most notably Turok 3 because I loved Turok 2 when I was younger and I remember being quite enraged.

Most recently:

Final Fantasy 13
Dragon Age 2
Kingdoms of Amalur
Fable 3
Halo 3
Rage
Uncharted 3
 

BloatedGuppy

New member
Feb 3, 2010
9,569
0
0
Anthraxus said:
Totally disagree about New Vegas. It was SOOO much better than the turd that was Fallout 3, for reasons that's been gone over time and time again.

I do agree about MotB being the best work Obsidian has done story-wise though.
I think I went on and on in another thread on this subject about how I never really appreciated Fallout for the story, it was always about the atmosphere and the mise-en-scene. Pretty much true of Elder Scrolls as well, now that I think about it. The WAY in which I enjoy those games pretty much makes FO3 and NV interchangeable. I'm well familiar with the arguments in NV's favor though, and I don't doubt you've got a cogent argument backing up your opinion. It's just me.

I do have a soft spot for Obsidian though. Their involvement bumped my Wasteland 2 investment up to the next tier, and I even enjoyed the heck out of Alpha Protocol.
 

Wintermoot

New member
Aug 20, 2009
6,559
0
0
Duke Nukem Forever
I was expecting witty remarks and a fun run-n-gun gameplay like HL1/2 but with the duke
instead I got a COD-ish experience with dated jokes.

or COD Black Ops
I was expecting a fun SP set in the heigght of the cold war
and I got a short as ass SP with game getting prized down in a week or so

....I want my money back that,s 120 euro,s for games that lasted me less then a day!
 

BrionJames

New member
Jul 8, 2009
540
0
0
Final Fantasy X

It started the whole, animated porcelain-skinned mannequins type people for that game franchise and I hate it for that reason alone. That and the awful voice-acting.
 

Wereduck

New member
Jun 17, 2010
382
0
0
MOO 3 was definitely my most worstest ever.
Two honorable mentions definitely go to this year's ME3 and SRTT though, not for being awful - both are thoroughly enjoyable - but for delivering significantly less awesome than their predecessors. Both made real improvements but then screwed up equally or more-important things that they'd already done beautifully years before. MOO3, by contrst, completely bitched up everything it touched.
 

sketch_zeppelin

New member
Jan 22, 2010
1,121
0
0
This isn't so much one of the biggest game disappointments in my life, rather one of the most recent. (SPOILER) I finally sat down and beat Hydrophobia...and then i had to replay the last checkpoint to make sure i didn't acidently skip a final cutscene or somthing. The game actually just ends after you hack a computer and round a corner. theres a cutscene of you being saved from a goon, you say you have to save someone named Skoot and then water floods into the area as you try to run from it and....thats it. the level ends and the credits role...

i've played games like Army of two 40th day that have terrible endings but Hydrophobia doesn't even have an ending...i'm not even sure you could call it a cliffhanger. the game just stops. Its not a great game to begin with but its literally like the developers ran out of time, money, or patience and said "Alright just finish the level and turn the lights off where out of here"