I like Kotick. Not meaning I like him personally or what he says, but as a stockholder I appreciate the money he makes me. To be honest, I liked Brutal Legend, but at the same time I'm glad they dropped it since it would never had made back the costs of producing it which would've hurt me financially.
Then we always here the people say they hate Kotick and Activision because they never take chances and go with the safe games. There are plenty of companies out there doing different games, doing arty games, doing innovative games, etc. If every company were to specialize in those, then gaming would die since nobody would be able to find the safe, normal games that they enjoy. Newcomers already think using any current control method (other than the Wii) is too dificult and the games themselves are too complex, so having Activision making games that anyone can play like Spider-Man, COD or the Hero games brings people into games and lets them buid up their confidence to try Valve or Bioware games.