Hmmm, well I have nothing against joke characters. No worse than Gon when you get down to it. Penny Arcade is good enough where they deserve the credit, though arguably I'm still waiting for Yahtzee to show up in a video game.
As far as skill vs. Button Mashing it's a matter of debate to be honest, since people tend to call anyone they lose to a button masher. For example I'm not a great player, but I was accused of being a Button Masher because I was able to dominate a lot of people who thought they were good because they could pull of highly technical moves and combos, simply by knowing how to sidestep and land basic attacks at the right time. "OMG you trashed me with two basic attacks, your a button masher".
I had roughly a 50% win rate in SC IV even with soooo many disconnects and poor sportsmanship complaints.
The thing is that unless your dealing with a kid who is playing for the first time there is no such thing as a button masher. Simply you have guys who get really technical and try and play it as a mental exercise outthinking their opponents, and guys who master a few basic things and then learn to adapt them to differant circumstances.
Now granted the best players tend to do both of these things, but most of the people who THINK they are on that level really aren't.
I mean you can say pwn a lot of self declared "masters" by simply spamming two of Sophitia's basic attack buttons and timing your sidesteps more (only throwing in something differant to mix it up a bit). You can do this with a lot of characters (though I was using Sophitia before she was considered 'high tier' or 'overpowered' I like to think I'm partially responsible from when the game first came out).
The problem I have with fighting games though is that they tend to make some of the characters too powerful or too easy to use without enough testing, and I mean this for real. All comments about "practice more" and "learn to play", in like SF IV I simply found it annoying to see soooo many Kens, Ryus, and Sagats. If Sagat had any more priority he would put Fed Ex out of business. In SC IV it was bloody Kilik, Nightmare, and Siegfried. It's not that there is no skill involved in those characters (or can't be) it's just that the way they are designed they are just so bloody overused in multiplayer that it's unreal.
Before I got bored I was using Zangief in SF IV, but I guess he's considered overpowered now too.
>>>----Therumancer--->