Lost Odyssey - I hated this game, I literally forced myself to play it because it was my only game that I owned that I hadn't played a million times over.
The gamestop guy raved about it, reviews rave about it, fans raved about it on all of these message boards.
I drooled over the videos of it because I like turn based JRPGs. But the game was so boring, I groaned repeatedly whenever I started it up in an effort to finish it (so I could sell it back to Gamestop).
I got to this one part on disc 3 where you have to run through a crowd of people and literally every step forced you into a random battle, but the game had taken away all of your team members and left you weak as hell; I had used up all of my potions so every battle was really getting closed to forcing me into a game over screen however, I made it through it (a crowd of people about 15 ft in size, took about 30 minutes to run through because of random battles) and what is my reward? a 3 hour sewer-puzzle with levers and gates.
UGH! I had made it to disc 3 of 4 and couldn't stand it any more. The game threw anything and everything it could at you to try to prolong its game life artificially, it was just so bad. The dream sequences were great text stories but most people don't buy games to read a book. I didn't find the gameplay or story appealing enough to suffer through for the great dream-stories.
Plus, most JRPGs give you a wide selection of characters to choose from to increase replay value. Lost Odyssey assumes you're going to love ALL of the characters and take time away from progression the story to grind ALL of the characters up. WHY it assumes this is beyond me but it likes to switch around your characters and force you to play with a different party setup constantly throughout the game. Don't like a character? Didn't bother leveling it up? Guess what... you have some grinding to do. Get stuck with more than one character you didn't bother leveling? (the chibi pre-teen twins are this for most people) now you have to start over, because you're too weak to fight random battles and bosses wipe the floor with you. Thanks for taking away my party members, game!
Okay that was way too much ranting about one game... I wanted to do several but I'll just have to be thankful with the one.
Edit: Okay can't resist, Oblivion disappointed me. I'll go into detail if someone asks why.