1337mokro said:
CaptainKarma said:
1337mokro said:
You could punch Zeus into a bloody pulp. But when it happens to a woman. MISOGYNY! BRUTAL! EVIL!
Oh please! You could get a trophy for banging all the women in the game, who I would like to remind you are nothing more but sex objects in these games. No misogyny here. Nothing to worry about.
Fuck you! Lara Croft gets impaled through the head on spikes and I didn't see Adam Sessler stirring up a storm for this controversial unnecessary brutality that actually made me a feel uncomfortable. A pointless trophy in a franchise that prides itself on ultra violence and sex is what gets highlighted instead.
To get worked up over this is to get worked up about the Chinese store in my neighborhood that still has a giant sign over it saying Oriental. Because we collectively decided that Oriental was now offensive to.
Fuck Sessler and all the other PC pansies out there.
Did you even read the article? Or watch the video? The issue is explicitly NOT about beating up a woman. It's about a tasteless joke that implies that it is funny to beat up a woman SPECIFICALLY because she's a woman. That's gross.
Yes and it loses on BOTH fucking fronts. It is both an act of violence that is overshadowed by other acts of violence AND jokes like these are RAMPANT about male death/mutilation. Do I have to point out the Nutshots in Saints Row, Sniper Elite, a slew of other online shooter which are basically a joke on themselves about physical injury to males? Do I have to go through lists and lists and lists of achievements to gather a nice bag of joke achievements involving violence to men? I think I don't need to because we both know they exist.
Where was the uproar there? There was none because violence against men is funny! If you don't believe me watch Django unchained. Try not to laugh during the last shoot out and then compare the MASSIVE amount of violence to the way a woman dies in that movie. Day and fucking night because people get squeamish about female death/mutilation merely by the fact that it is a woman.
PC garbage is what this is nothing more.
You are very angry about changing a joke to not be demeaning to women. Think on that.
The issue, as the review said, as the article said, as I have said, as every fucking sensible person has said, is NOT that the game endorses violence against women. It is NOT that the game makes violence against women a joke. The issue is that the game makes a joke about violence against women BECAUSE they are women.
Yes, there are jokes made about male-specific violence (I won't lie, nut-shots are funny). But there is a difference between violence committed by men against men. In action movies and games etc nearly all violence is from a male perspective. It's men doing it, it's men receiving it. It's not a scene in which "a man gets shot in the nuts", it's a scene in which "a person gets shot in the nuts". The male is the default so the sexual nature is less of an issue. In a world without sexism we could make jokes about EVERYONE being shot in the genitals (and what a world that would be), but the problem with the achievement is that it implies a nasty "haha take that, wimmin!" attitude.
Father Time said:
Anyway if you're passionate about your work you should resist self censorship wherever possible.
What? Why? How is self censorship a bad thing? Self censorship just seems to me to be the ability to step back and think "is this saying what I want it say, and ONLY what I want it to say, or is going to be hurtful/insulting in a way I don't intend". That's a damn good thing to do.
debigcheez said:
You seem to forget that this thread has over 100 replies.
And? That's nothing. It's a tiny thread. It's all irrelevant anyway. People could be massively overreacting and it wouldn't magically make the joke any more tasteful. I apologise if I'm misinterpreting you, but it does seem to me that you're using "you're overreacting" as code for "the original achievement is fine" which is a nonsense argument.