Grey Carter said:
Optimystic said:
I don't have a lot of sympathy for that lady. Running a private server I don't see the harm in, but if you want to charge people for stuff, invent your own damn game.
Agreed. My biggest worry is that this case sets a precedent that could affect cases involving pirate servers for games without monthly fees, I touched on that in the strip.
Running a pirate WOW server is a clear cut case of good/bad but how about running a Modern Warfare 2 server or any other game that dissalows dedicated servers.
Perhaps... Personally, I think the only clear-cut "bad" here is
profiting from said server-running, as making money off someone else's property is clearly unjust enrichment.
Would she have been
as in the wrong if she were doing it for free though? And I know, running servers isn't cheap, but she would have at least had the defense that this was a recreational venture and not a commercial one. A-B would have looked then even more fiendish than they already do.
But that would mean: no donations, no fees, no microtransactions, no accepting revenue of any kind from her guests - not unless she's willing to publish statements proving that all the money goes purely to upkeep, which would tip her hand anyway.
So I guess I'm asking - if someone were to host a private server like this just to play with their friends away from the stresses of the general population, and footed the bill entirely out of pocket, would that person be just as wrong? And this goes for any kind of multiplayer game that would benefit from a dedicated server, not just MMOs.