Critical Miss: Tet Rising
- Thread starter The Wooster
- Start date
Recommended Videos
This is bloody genius. How didn't anyone think of that joke before?
You should make an entire series of Frank's amazing war photos. It would be at once the best and worst thing ever.
You should make an entire series of Frank's amazing war photos. It would be at once the best and worst thing ever.
It worked for the Fascists. They... they won, right?Gethsemani said:
Atchooly, he is: an American-style fatigue shirt. This was during the second day of the Tet Offensive, involving some of the most vicious fighting of the war, and most combatants in-theater got to looking pretty rumpled by that point.Witty Name Here said:
The shooter is Brigadier General Nguyen Ngoc Loan, head of South Vietnam's national police force. The deceased was, as noted above, a captain in charge of a Viet Cong murder squad specifically tasked with killing cops and their families. Since he was caught wearing civilian clothes instead of a uniform, the Geneva Conventions did not protect him from summary execution.
The American photographer long regretted taking the picture, particularly since to his knowledge Loan was a genuine Vietnamese war hero. Loan later lost his leg to machinegun fire while leading a charge against Viet Cong positions, and after being relieved of his command due to the injuries, devoted his time to setting up hospitals and the helping of Vietnamese war orphans.
Personally, I'm not a fan of making humour out of infamous footage of a real person being shot.
There's a line where bad taste starts and this is way beyond it.
It's not edgy in my view and I didn't like it.
With that said, I'm sure we won't see more of the same so I just wanted to note that this one made me feel quite disgusted rather than enjoy the work.
Sorry to have to say this about a comic I've liked up until now.
There's a line where bad taste starts and this is way beyond it.
It's not edgy in my view and I didn't like it.
With that said, I'm sure we won't see more of the same so I just wanted to note that this one made me feel quite disgusted rather than enjoy the work.
Sorry to have to say this about a comic I've liked up until now.
But, if the entire joke is about a character having a clear sense of poor taste - ie claiming to be a sophisticated war correspondent at the same that he duct tapes chainsaws to hockey sticks and hacks through the undead, surely such an image is warranted?Silva said:
It's not actually making light of the picture, it's holding the picture up as an example of the discrepancy between actual war correspondence and some twat in a video game claiming to be a big deal. I think just getting disgusted out of principle is missing the point entirely.
On a different note, what's with the speech bubble police in the Facebook comments? The conventions of style exist to most effectively convey a point, and in this case, the point is that he's being an annoying ass and talking over her. If that's the case, it doesn't freaking matter which side the arrows are on...
I donno. My money's on that guy trolling people, but you can never underestimate stupidity.Shamanic Rhythm said:
Somebody ought to link him to several newspaper comics and/or famous western works so he has a chance to jump out of the well. Quite a lot of them break speech bubble conventions more often than not.
Edit: My first three searches broke all of the conventions he was complaining about...
Dilbert
http://www.dilbert.com/
Garfield
http://www.garfield.com/comics/vault.html?yr=2011&addr=111021
(link is to the first comic which contains a speech bubble instead of a thought bubble)
Peanuts
http://www.peanuts.com/comics/
(And somebody ought to link him to old Mad Magazine strips. I still remember those loooooong linked word bubbles)
Where I don't necessarily agree with all of the guy's arguments on my bubble placement he does make a few fair points, and to be fair, I am just learning bubble placement now as the comic goes on and I don't mind the points being brought up. The bubbling isn't completely clear and that is a design flaw on my part that I will be more conscious of from now on.
There were many different factors leading to the first panel as it was, but I still love the panel. I actually loved doing the lines for the computer at that angle with Suchong peering over the edge, and I got a little too caught up in how I liked how the panel was framed I didn't consider what to do with Greys words after the lines were lain down.
As far as tails pointing to mouths, I'm not a fan of that convention.
I don't think mouths need to be open if that person is talking, I have always seen a panel as a picture of a single point in time. So in some instances it would make sense for people to be talking over one another, but for that panel the point in time I drew was right when Frank was coming into the room.
But Frank's words should have been on the left and I should have planned out the panels all a bit better.
There were many different factors leading to the first panel as it was, but I still love the panel. I actually loved doing the lines for the computer at that angle with Suchong peering over the edge, and I got a little too caught up in how I liked how the panel was framed I didn't consider what to do with Greys words after the lines were lain down.
As far as tails pointing to mouths, I'm not a fan of that convention.
I don't think mouths need to be open if that person is talking, I have always seen a panel as a picture of a single point in time. So in some instances it would make sense for people to be talking over one another, but for that panel the point in time I drew was right when Frank was coming into the room.
But Frank's words should have been on the left and I should have planned out the panels all a bit better.
Those aren't Frank's lines, though. That garbage was Chuck's thing (and yet another reason why I couldn't stand Chuck), but they didn't better change the dialog to make it fit Frank. They just changed Chuck's puns around and made Frank say them. It's actually pretty piss poor writing on the part of the developers. Am I playing as Frank West, or Chuck Greene wearing a Frank skin? Because in every one of those pun scenes, it feels like the latter which is a disgrace. Off the Record was supposed to be Frank's game, not Chuck's game.Onyx Oblivion said:
Why are you blaming the character? it's the player that makes the decision whether he wears that crazy stuff or not!
Just like Yahtzee's Prototype review when HE drove an APC over civilians to get to his destination and blames it on Alex Mercer, saying that somehow it was his fault...
Just like Yahtzee's Prototype review when HE drove an APC over civilians to get to his destination and blames it on Alex Mercer, saying that somehow it was his fault...