Beautiful End said:
ScottocS said:
BlackWidower said:
I'm in the middle of her path, and I so far love it. The reason I hated Emi was because she was a dumb *****:
"I can't let you get close."
Then what the fuck are we doing!? What's worse is that she's completely oblivious to her faux pas. It's pathetic. She's a horrible human being.
Having stuck with Emi's path through my first play through, I got hooked somehow into getting to know more or pushing on to understand why she feels the way she does, because of the 'I can't get close to you' theme. Yeah, it was a tad annoying but I was happy with how they resolved it all in the end.
Being my first visual novel, I was surprised at the emotions that could be drawn from the choices I made (especially with Emi's "rollercoaster-ride" attitude). I'm looking forward to the other arcs and am glad a friend recommended it to me.
This. Just this.
Emi was also my first instinctive choice. I was shooting for Hanako but I ended up with her, which forced me to try and understand her better. Amazingly, I got her good ending on my very first try. There were times when I just had to stop and think of the best answer and how she would reply.
However, so far, I think I'm liking Rin's path a bit more...
I don't think any of the other paths are quite as well written or have quite as interesting a character. Rin's story is in my opinion the most engaging and heartrending/warming of them all. What most people don't realize about Rin is that whatever she says, she means... she is always serious and tells the absolute truth the way she sees it, she just has some serious trouble putting her thoughts to words in a way that is easy to understand without paying close attention.
Shizune's story could have gotten close if it wasn't for the horribly out-of-place character of her father the grumpy-mullet-sword-man... seriously, way to ruin an otherwise great story of serious romantic drama with misplaced and overdone comic relief.
Hanako's story could also have been great, had it not been for her being so much of a typical moe character during most of the story that it feels very jarring when she finally starts breaking out of that mold. It's great that she does, but I can't help but feel that it would have been more believable and effective had they toned down the moe-dial just a bit.
Lilly's was pretty damned good. I'd say it's about on par with Hanako's story and Lilly has a refreshingly small amount of emotional baggage to deal with... there is some, but it's not the main point of her story.
I didn't much like the ending of Emi's story. I just really don't like the whole "I lost someone I loved and it hurt, so now I'll never love again so I can't get hurt." thing. It's just such an overdone cliché. I liked the rest of the story though, when it wanted to be heartwarming it really was, and when it wanted to be sad it really was. I could see the ending coming, but really hoped it wasn't what I assumed it would be, and I was let down. I had thoroughly hoped that instead of her dad just being dead, he'd still be alive and well, but having been responsible for the crash that took her legs, he had been unable to face his wife and daughter again, falling apart emotionally and leaving Emi and her mother with the burden of uncertainty and stress of trying to get him over his issues as well as getting over their own.
But no... he was just dead.