I only buy about 2 or 3 new titles a year (and a few well-reviewed older titles when steam has a sale). As a result I have to be picky. I used to pre-order quite a bit and was often happy with the games I grabbed (Fallout 3 and Bioshock) but I have also been let down by games that were less than I hoped (Diablo 3 and Crysis 2). As a result I am going to just wait and see with games. What do reviewers say and why do they say it?
For example I am looking forward to Bioshock Infinite. What I am hoping to hear is that the setting is well-realized, the atmosphere is genuinely scary and the plot/characters are interesting - all assuming that it's game-play is not terrible (an FPS doesn't need to be original in the game-play department). If reviewers say that sort of thing about the game I will grab it because that is what I am looking for - even if it has flaws in other areas (can't be gaping ones) I other words; it doesn't need to be the perfect game but it will need to match the promises made by it's marketing/advertising.
For example I am looking forward to Bioshock Infinite. What I am hoping to hear is that the setting is well-realized, the atmosphere is genuinely scary and the plot/characters are interesting - all assuming that it's game-play is not terrible (an FPS doesn't need to be original in the game-play department). If reviewers say that sort of thing about the game I will grab it because that is what I am looking for - even if it has flaws in other areas (can't be gaping ones) I other words; it doesn't need to be the perfect game but it will need to match the promises made by it's marketing/advertising.