Jamcie Kerbizz said:
Read what you write. I ignored previous straw men (the whole people are garbage) but you just sipral out of control on this nonsense. Stop arguing with your own 'interpretation' of my words. You're wasting everyones time. Precisely that's how much is left when you cross out BS assumptions and ranting.
You made it a fucking example. I was critiquing the example.
How else do you want me to articulate my position?
To me a friend is someone that I can ring up and can help me with a mechanical problem I might have if I break down somewhere, by picking up some tools and a flashlight and going out of their way to meet me somewhere so I can work on a problem. To actually bring it within the realms of mundanity... That to me seems like a reasonable degree of a friend helping a friend that most people would consider a pretty good measure.
Or helping take care of your dog on a business trip. Or helping keep an eye on your house while you're gone, making it seem like someone is actually at home by collecting your mail and occasionally turning on and off the lights.
Is that a better one?
I know more than 1-2 people worthy of that consideration, however. People I honestly believe would do such a thing if able. Moreover it's stuff I would do for them if able, as well.
I can't promise I can bring a spare tire on my motorbike ... but I'll meet someone with a tankbag full of tools and have a go with them inspecting their motor to see if we can get it running with whatever I can bring.
Now we get to sudo-specialists, which abuse people who are insecure about their social life choices and try to drum up such fears. Literally damaging mental health of people by instigating that there's something wrong with them because they don't act like others expect them to (after such 'psychotherapy'my friend stopped leaving the house because she was afraid of the sheer pressure to do something she didn't feel like doing). Actual professional would inquire why someone does that (don't feel like socializing) and guide person toward like minded people or reassure them that there is nothing wrong with them (some people get exhausted by socializing and there is plethora of reasosns for that eg. intellectually inferrior people to spend time with, mind that tends to focus on details, unique individual interests and tastes etc. others get boosted by it). Don't know what sort of specialists you have met, that would drug someone over 'not socializing enough'.
Christ, what exactly does this have to do with the subject matter? If people are insecure about their social life and have serious anxiety problems that actually
affect the quality of their life to the point where it's manifesting into serious concerns as to their mental health then yeah, it might call for psychotherapy. That is not taboo, it's an accepted part of treatment. We have services to meet these health concerns if people want to engage with them. Nobody is saying involuntary hospitalization is required for people just because they feel a bit nervous around too many people.
Moreover, what exactly is it you think people who run psychotherapy services do? Things like IPT is all about helping people examine their own behaviour that might be affecting their capacity to engage with others, for instance.
It's an empirically supported treatment option for numerous types of major depressive disorders. It doesn't just target people for 'being weird' ... it's there to assist people find new means to form closer human attachments if that would adequately help them. It also helps in other indirect ways, like examining how people engage with others in order to be more aware of how they engage in conventional relationships such as the workplace. Possibly improving job security and esteem, which is conducive to dealing with other latent anxiety issues.
It's not healthy to assume people will only ever associate with others that they will get along with. The grand majority of us have professional and personal contact with people we simply
do not like but have to deal with. Whether that be neighbours, work associates and so forth.
If a person is crippled by the inability to examine how their actions might jeopardise maintaining these relationships or understanding the crucial link to how these relationships affect moods and this is seriously impacting on their mental health, then why exactly is things like CBT and IPT bad? People can't only just associate with "like-minded people" ... the real world doesn't work like that.