Susan Arendt said:
You know, I don't claim to know everything. I haven't read every book, seen every movie, or played every game. I invite others to educate me about what I don't know, and I'll do likewise for them when the opportunity presents itself.
This was an opportunity for you to educate me on something I didn't know. Instead you went for a snide remark. Shame, really.
This is a classic reply, one intended both to invoke the "human fallability" clause, and to evoke guilt in me. But I actually did educate you, by mentioning the book. And, as I wrote in my last posts, I truly meant no offense. In fact, I figured my first post would be a far more easy-going way of pointing out that I Am Legend is a phenomenon older than the recent movie than most alternatives.
As you probably know, every message carries two meanings: the one intended by the sender, and the one perceived by the receiver. You might have perceived my message as snarky and offensive, but in truth, it was not intended as such. Of course, I might be to blame for the misperception, just as you might. Regardless of whether I am, or not, I am sorry for whatever offense I caused you.
But, more importantly, we have something in common: we are both schooled writers, with degrees in journalism. So, we both know just how easy it is to run a quick (quick, as in half a minute, at the most) background check or source reliability test on almost *ANYTHING* we write. If we want to draw parallels that expore the intentions of the writers of a movie, in comparison to a game, a quick Wikipedia search will tell us exactly if there is any possibility that movie-makers might have been inspired by a particular computer game. In this case, it would have revealed to you that I Am Legend is inspired by a book, and that the dog in question probably (probably, since I certainly don't claim to be certain) has nothing to do with Dogmeat.
Doing this for every little piece we write sounds trite or redundant? Nope. Source criticism and evaluation is the one element of journalism that never grows old, never goes out of style, and that is SO easy to rely on, even if you are just composing a three sentence press item regarding runaway kittens. It really only takes a few seconds, with today's access to online information, and is sure to improve the quality of *any* piece.