Frauds Plague Steam's Greenlight

[Canadamus Prime]

I noticed a number of 'em looked less than legit, although I haven't seen anything offensive though. I have seen a number of obvious Minecraft clones.

 

[DEaViL]

- give greenlight some time.
some things just don't work instantly, especially when it's reliant on other people.



- also can someone please tell me something?
when exactly did valve say they were working on HL3?

i'm getting tired of fan whines saying they're delaying it when they have never said they were working on it to begin with.

and yes, i know about the episodes but i'm also sure that was discontinued

THX

 

[l3o2828]

And yet we don't have No One Lives Forever games on Steam.

 

[Treblaine]

But I'm not surprised at the backlash at Half Life, it's mainly from console players who would rather play the latest degree iteration of Call Of Duty: Aim-Assist Warfare and have consternation at a series like Half Life getting acclaim when it's not about burly military men shooting endless waves of Russians in the exact same way over, and over, and over again but rather about the purity of FPS immersion and seamless storytelling.

No, no it's not. It's about people sick of very vocal fans of a single presumably-aborted franchise bringing up a non-existent, no-longer-relevant game in EVERY SINGLE ARTICLE about the largest, most popular digital-distribution company. And yes, I have played Half-life and Half-life 2.

And I'm mostly a PC gamer.

Oh come on, why is this so much with Half Life but not with the likes of Mass Effect or other fandoms?

No longer relevant? Yahtzee has said often enough that he's fed up with what passes for innovation in 2012 being nothing but catching up with what Valve did in 2004. Half Life 2 and episodes were hugely popular and ended on a cliffhanger with promise of resolution. It's very relevant.

And it is very relevant in this article WHICH DIRECTLY ADDRESSES HALF LIFE 3!!!!

"Steam's Greenlight service has deleted five versions of Half Life 3..."

" It didn't take long before games that existed in name only or were obvious attempts to troll - Half Life 3, Left 4 Dead 3,"

""I've already seen just in the last HOUR two entries for Mass Effect 3, five various entries for Half Life 3 ... ""

"Greenlight is there to meet your needs. Just no Half Life 3. Sorry 'bout that."


Four. Four references. Somehow not relevant.

This is nothing but backlash of "well I don't care, but I care that you care".

 

[Treblaine]

This Greenlight thing is a huge pile of shit. It went just as i predicted. filled to the brim with generic uninteresting games, lazily made, 50% of wich are blatant ripoffs of other games, without any imagination or effort to differentiate and add interesting thigns to them.

What's the matter with rip-offs?

Imagine if after Doom or Quake it was verboten to be "so unoriginal" to make an FPS. Remember for the first 10 years of FPS games they were all called "doom clones" or when in 3D "Quake clones".

As long as the rip-offs are good and not level-by-level clones then what is the problem?

Why is it OK for a developer to make a very similar derivative just as long as they call it a sequel?

 

[draythefingerless]

This Greenlight thing is a huge pile of shit. It went just as i predicted. filled to the brim with generic uninteresting games, lazily made, 50% of wich are blatant ripoffs of other games, without any imagination or effort to differentiate and add interesting thigns to them.

What's the matter with rip-offs?

Imagine if after Doom or Quake it was verboten to be "so unoriginal" to make an FPS. Remember for the first 10 years of FPS games they were all called "doom clones" or when in 3D "Quake clones".

As long as the rip-offs are good and not level-by-level clones then what is the problem?

Why is it OK for a developer to make a very similar derivative just as long as they call it a sequel?

you DO notice the part in my post where i mention they are ripoffs with irrelevant levels of differentiation or imagination inputted right? im not the kind of guy who would call evth a COD clone, but i know blatant lazy ripoffs when i see them. all over the GreenLight pages.

 

[dfphetteplace]

I saw one that was an African American simulator. The picture was a prison. Obvious BS. Reported and moved on.

 

[Vigormortis]

I wouldn't exactly call it "the elephant in the room" when they've explicitly stated they're not working on it right now.

It indeed is getting ridiculous with Half Life 3, but only due to the continuous and unrelenting squealing of fanboys every time they find another way to tell themselves that Valve maybe is secretly working on it after all.

Actually, it's quite the opposite.

Gabe Newell himself has said that they are currently working on Half-Life 3. And, that they have been since Episode 2 finished.

I'm not sure where people keep getting this idea that they're not. Kind of puzzling, really.

Relevant link: http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2012/04/23/gabe-on-ricochet-2-delay-but-he-doesnt-mean-ricochet/

- also can someone please tell me something?
when exactly did valve say they were working on HL3?

i'm getting tired of fan whines saying they're delaying it when they have never said they were working on it to begin with.

and yes, i know about the episodes but i'm also sure that was discontinued

THX

Can we honestly just stop mentioning HL3 in every thread relating to Valve? It gets a bit tiresome when some people can't even talk about the subject at hand without twisting it back around to that one game they keep saying they want more than a wish granting genie which isn't being made yet.

As for Greenlight, yeah, big surprise there are issues when it just came out. It's something no company has ever done before and Valve are literally striking new ground with it. Kind of like they did when they originally released Steam. Getting all doom and gloom about it is a bit silly before they've had the chance to work on ironing out the problems. I've no doubt that it will run much more smoothly in the future.

Hell, if it's doing a decent job of weeding out the fakes and the thieves already then in time it may work as disincentive to their trying to get past the crowd if it's not working.

See above.

Also, this Escapist article mentions Half-Life 3 roughly four times. It's not really a stretch to see people mentioning it in the comments.

Just sayin'.

 

[Vigormortis]

These sorts of services are ALWAYS bound to have a load of garbage piling on the good. It's inevitable.

Still, I'm loving Greenlight, thus far. Especially considering it's bringing more attention to gems like Project Zomboid.

 

[unstabLized]

And yet we don't have No One Lives Forever games on Steam.

I wish for that too. NOLF is epic.

 

[Woodsey]

This is getting ridiculous with Half Life 3, we've been waiting 8 years now, 5 since Episode 2 and we have not seen or heard a peep of anything, we don't even know if it is still in production.

Right, so it's been a 5-year wait. I assume you don't say that the last shit you took was the shit you shit 5 shits ago. Or... something.

I wouldn't exactly call it "the elephant in the room" when they've explicitly stated they're not working on it right now.

It indeed is getting ridiculous with Half Life 3, but only due to the continuous and unrelenting squealing of fanboys every time they find another way to tell themselves that Valve maybe is secretly working on it after all.

Well, it is being worked on. Not sure where you heard your explicit statement.

http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2012/04/23/gabe-on-ricochet-2-delay-but-he-doesnt-mean-ricochet/

 

[nasteypenguin]

This Greenlight thing is a huge pile of shit. It went just as i predicted. filled to the brim with generic uninteresting games, lazily made, 50% of wich are blatant ripoffs of other games, without any imagination or effort to differentiate and add interesting thigns to them.

I still think it's a good idea, Greenlight was always going to be a filter I'm pretty sure everyone predicted that. Filters are always filled with 99% crap, it's job is to siphon out the good games that are usually buried under the layers of said crap. Greenlight is just a way of reducing the human errors you get when you normally rely on a small team of people to do a job that is based largely on opinion.

 

[Rednog]

I still don't even know why Valve is bothering with greenlight, why not just accept every indie game that developers bring to them? It's not like they have a standard of quality they are trying to keep, they've let absolute garbage on steam.

 

[Scow2]

But I'm not surprised at the backlash at Half Life, it's mainly from console players who would rather play the latest degree iteration of Call Of Duty: Aim-Assist Warfare and have consternation at a series like Half Life getting acclaim when it's not about burly military men shooting endless waves of Russians in the exact same way over, and over, and over again but rather about the purity of FPS immersion and seamless storytelling.

No, no it's not. It's about people sick of very vocal fans of a single presumably-aborted franchise bringing up a non-existent, no-longer-relevant game in EVERY SINGLE ARTICLE about the largest, most popular digital-distribution company. And yes, I have played Half-life and Half-life 2.

And I'm mostly a PC gamer.

Oh come on, why is this so much with Half Life but not with the likes of Mass Effect or other fandoms?

No longer relevant? Yahtzee has said often enough that he's fed up with what passes for innovation in 2012 being nothing but catching up with what Valve did in 2004. Half Life 2 and episodes were hugely popular and ended on a cliffhanger with promise of resolution. It's very relevant.

And it is very relevant in this article WHICH DIRECTLY ADDRESSES HALF LIFE 3!!!!

"Steam's Greenlight service has deleted five versions of Half Life 3..."

" It didn't take long before games that existed in name only or were obvious attempts to troll - Half Life 3, Left 4 Dead 3,"

""I've already seen just in the last HOUR two entries for Mass Effect 3, five various entries for Half Life 3 ... ""

"Greenlight is there to meet your needs. Just no Half Life 3. Sorry 'bout that."


Four. Four references. Somehow not relevant.

This is nothing but backlash of "well I don't care, but I care that you care".

So Yahtzee's ignorant about what game innovation really is, and has really weird ideas about what makes a game a game (See - his complete missing of the point of random dungeon layouts in dungeon-crawlers). What else is new?

The problem I had with your comment was entirely with your attack on everyone annoyed by the incessant whining about Half-Life 3's need to come out is not just angry that it's not "their" favored franchise (Which you moronically assume is Call of Duty, which you then ignorantly and grossly misrepresent), and that they're intellectually inferior and incapable of thinking for themselves [http://xkcd.com/610/].

 

[draythefingerless]

This Greenlight thing is a huge pile of shit. It went just as i predicted. filled to the brim with generic uninteresting games, lazily made, 50% of wich are blatant ripoffs of other games, without any imagination or effort to differentiate and add interesting thigns to them.

I still think it's a good idea, Greenlight was always going to be a filter I'm pretty sure everyone predicted that. Filters are always filled with 99% crap, it's job is to siphon out the good games that are usually buried under the layers of said crap. Greenlight is just a way of reducing the human errors you get when you normally rely on a small team of people to do a job that is based largely on opinion.

i dont think GreenLight is all without potential. But right now GreenLight is the equivalent of the Android app store. shit upon shit upon shit, with little to no control of quality and plagiarism. I do not find the rare find worth the pile of things punted into it. Not to mention i believe that most hits as you would call it are mere luck, seeing that most good games dont get needed fame anyway. Something like the Apple app store is what it should be.

 

[Signa]

And yet we don't have No One Lives Forever games on Steam.

Good point. Day-one buys for me, just like the Thief series. I still have my disks, but I like owning them on my account for convenience sake.

 

[Treblaine]

This is getting ridiculous with Half Life 3, we've been waiting 8 years now, 5 since Episode 2 and we have not seen or heard a peep of anything, we don't even know if it is still in production.

Right, so it's been a 5-year wait. I assume you don't say that the last shit you took was the shit you shit 5 shits ago. Or... something.

WHAT!!!!

What does me ceasing defecation for half a decade have to do with this?

My issue is not JUST that it hasn't been released... but that we have had not update or clear indication of commitment.

 

[Treblaine]

This Greenlight thing is a huge pile of shit. It went just as i predicted. filled to the brim with generic uninteresting games, lazily made, 50% of wich are blatant ripoffs of other games, without any imagination or effort to differentiate and add interesting thigns to them.

What's the matter with rip-offs?

Imagine if after Doom or Quake it was verboten to be "so unoriginal" to make an FPS. Remember for the first 10 years of FPS games they were all called "doom clones" or when in 3D "Quake clones".

As long as the rip-offs are good and not level-by-level clones then what is the problem?

Why is it OK for a developer to make a very similar derivative just as long as they call it a sequel?

you DO notice the part in my post where i mention they are ripoffs with irrelevant levels of differentiation or imagination inputted right? im not the kind of guy who would call evth a COD clone, but i know blatant lazy ripoffs when i see them. all over the GreenLight pages.

Sorry, I didn't appreciate that part of your post.

Did any glaring cases of plagirism-like rip-offing stand out enough to you that you could point them out to the thread?

 

[Treblaine]

But I'm not surprised at the backlash at Half Life, it's mainly from console players who would rather play the latest degree iteration of Call Of Duty: Aim-Assist Warfare and have consternation at a series like Half Life getting acclaim when it's not about burly military men shooting endless waves of Russians in the exact same way over, and over, and over again but rather about the purity of FPS immersion and seamless storytelling.

No, no it's not. It's about people sick of very vocal fans of a single presumably-aborted franchise bringing up a non-existent, no-longer-relevant game in EVERY SINGLE ARTICLE about the largest, most popular digital-distribution company. And yes, I have played Half-life and Half-life 2.

And I'm mostly a PC gamer.

Oh come on, why is this so much with Half Life but not with the likes of Mass Effect or other fandoms?

No longer relevant? Yahtzee has said often enough that he's fed up with what passes for innovation in 2012 being nothing but catching up with what Valve did in 2004. Half Life 2 and episodes were hugely popular and ended on a cliffhanger with promise of resolution. It's very relevant.

And it is very relevant in this article WHICH DIRECTLY ADDRESSES HALF LIFE 3!!!!

"Steam's Greenlight service has deleted five versions of Half Life 3..."

" It didn't take long before games that existed in name only or were obvious attempts to troll - Half Life 3, Left 4 Dead 3,"

""I've already seen just in the last HOUR two entries for Mass Effect 3, five various entries for Half Life 3 ... ""

"Greenlight is there to meet your needs. Just no Half Life 3. Sorry 'bout that."


Four. Four references. Somehow not relevant.

This is nothing but backlash of "well I don't care, but I care that you care".

So Yahtzee's ignorant about what game innovation really is, and has really weird ideas about what makes a game a game (See - his complete missing of the point of random dungeon layouts in dungeon-crawlers). What else is new?

The problem I had with your comment was entirely with your attack on everyone annoyed by the incessant whining about Half-Life 3's need to come out is not just angry that it's not "their" favored franchise (Which you moronically assume is Call of Duty, which you then ignorantly and grossly misrepresent), and that they're intellectually inferior and incapable of thinking for themselves [http://xkcd.com/610/].

Hmmm, so Yahtzees opinion is objectively incorrect? He was talking about FPS games, not dungeon crawlers, now THAT is not relevant here.

Come on, you're not new to Escapist, you know how almost every other week another thread starts by someone like "Soap360" asking what's so important about Half life 2 complaining that it doesn't have a "good multiplayer" or even aim-down sights mechanic. Mods tend to lock or delete them though. You can't deny COD's huge popularity or how often the foul-mouthed community has been dismissive of Half Life series. It's a safe bet.

"intellectually inferior and incapable of thinking for themselves"

Lol nope. Re-read/read-for-the-fist-time my WHOLE post. No skimming.

That's XKCD comic is completely irrelevant, and I find it pretty disingenuous that you try to associate it.

 

[DanDeFool]

Okay, this thing turned out waaaay different than what I thought it was going to be.

I thought it would be complete or nearly-complete games that Valve was considering adding to their catalogue already that users could prioritize for them. Not something where any jerk could post anything they wanted.

Bottom line, I'm with those people who are saying they want to see finished games only on the list, and not have it be just another version of kickstarter.