Okay, generally the games I find are good because I've weighed the options and the possibility of fun to be had...and really I have a high probability of fun in whatever I buy. There ARE exceptions, but as people who know me and my rants would think...I don't want FF8 to be good. I just wish I never bought it.
No, I have a different game in mind, an older game. A friend of mine introduced me to a game which is FPS around the Quake era involving fighting, quests, character interaction, making choices, and kicking ass. (Yes, fighting and kicking ass need separate mentions.) The game was called Strife and it involved the world being bombarded from space and then taken over by basically armed cultist soldiers who serve...an entity of unknown origins. (Far too late for spoiler alerts, seriously.) Basically, the entity is taking over and spawning, and thus denies humanity the right to breed during its act of conquest.
Here's the thing. This game WASN'T bad. I played it and it's fun. The problem was the very thing you should have picked on in the previous paragraph. The game did poorly because it was released mere months before Quake, overshadowed by the competition. But thenm to be perfectly frank, better before than after, because then maybe the guys behind Strife wouldn't have seen ANY money. So, I guess what I wish is that it was good enough to make its own standing.