I didn't think it was that bad in all honesty. There was some pretty annoying flaws. Some of the voice acting was just down right awful, such as the witch who honestly made me want to rip my ears out. There was some weird graphical issues where wandering NPC's will walk through the NPC who you are talking to, which actually if anything made me laugh rather than get annoyed. There isn't any internal AA on the PC version either which frustrates me to no end. Hate games without AA. However, the actual gameplay was alright, and the story doesn't seem terrible either. The graphics are really nice if you can manage to ignore the jagged edges also. I don't think I'd pay full price for it, but I think I'll probably pick it up when it's cheaper, possibly.