Scow2 said:
Pogilrup said:
gargantual and Lupine
That's a lot like many other stories that came before this one.
By themselves, there is no problem with tales that contain events that lead to a tragic, virtually meaningless death of a female character.
However, taken together and they form a trend where predominant number of female characters are killed off just to motivate or test the will of a male protagonist.
This game is unfortunately yet another entry in that big list of works that use the Disposable Woman trope.
There are also a lot of stories where a lot of male characters are killed off just to motivate/test the will of male protagonists, but nobody cares about those guys. As far as I can tell, Metal Gear has had more sympathetic male characters get killed off to motivate/test the hero than females.
Well I can agree with the part about this being like stories that have come before. That is sort of where the concept of things being cliche comes from, except by the same token there are things that can be accepted as universal truths in literature or at the very least they don't require much exposition for the audience to understand as motivations.
As humans there are certain societal norms that reach across culture or time period, and so for the sake of expedience I'll call them universal truths even if they aren't universal in the personal but they tend to be so at least generally speaking. So, universal truth. People love their families. People are protective of their homes. People don't like their way of life forcefully changed against their will. Stories tend to be made of conflict. If you're breaking down things to their smallest and perhaps truest parts, most things are the same or at the very least similar. All of that is to ask the question, does it really matter that it is the same as other stories? If it did, archetypes wouldn't be such a part of the literary process I think. However as has already been pointed out, Metal Gear does this quite a bit, it plays on simplistic action tropes, sometimes straight sometimes subverted, but the tropes tend to mean less than the emotions experienced during the journey.
I'm not saying that Paz's death wasn't playing on the fridge trope or that her treatment isn't an example of kicking the puppy to show that the villain is really evil, however I am arguing that your assertion is wrong that these things together some how combines to make women disposable. If anything I'd point out that in most fiction and action fiction to say the least that people are disposable. Life is cheap. I remember reading this quote from Stephen King and as a writer myself I feel that it is probably the truest thing a man might have said about the art: ?Kill your darlings, kill your darlings, even when it breaks your egocentric little scribbler?s heart, kill your darlings."
As a writer it isn't about how you are attached to the characters, it isn't about how your cultural or religious leanings subconsciously touch your decisions as you write, more and more or at least if you are trying to be a good writer at any rate it comes down to what in your opinion is best for the story. However at the end of the day, it is your opinion. There might be better writers that see something you don't, there might be options that you don't realize you have because of your upbringing and personal experiences, but in the end it is your opinion that matters as the author of a particular work.
I'm not saying that no one has the right to question your decisions or discuss them, not by half. If you're a writer and you can't take criticism you might as well quit, but what I am saying is that something to you that seems like glaring misrepresentation or simulated woman abuse, might simply have never even occurred to Kojima. In fact I'm pretty sure it didn't, especially with the music at the time of Paz's death. I feel like for him this was Paz's big moment, she hadn't gotten to make a whole lot of choices in her life and suddenly she makes the one that decides the fate of the series. She was murdered sure, but she was also a martyr and a hero.
That's the thing about writing though, you don't get to pick what people see or don't see in your work. You just get to bare the little piece of yourself that you would and see what happens.