waj9876 said:
orangeban said:
I saw a newspaper use the slur "tranny" in their headline.
Tranny is a slur now? I've called transgendered people tranny before, hell, I've called a transgendered person I was INTERESTED IN DATING a tranny (still interested in dating them to this day), and in both cases they were totally cool with it.
(Oddly I've even been called a tranny before. I'm a little feminine looking, mostly the eyes and hair. Only took offense to the fact that I'm not transgendered.)
Yeah, tranny's a slur, and I can explain why.
Here's an experiment for you to try, though I'll warn that it's NSFW. Go on google images, turn off safe-search and google "trannys". You'll get porn. Lots of porn. Go into regular google and google "tranny". There's a wikipedia article, and then porn.
"Tranny" is directly connected with the sexual objectification and fetishisation of trans women. This means the word has serious negative, objectifying, dehumanising and humiliating connotations in today's society.
The word is also used by hate groups as a degrogatory term. If you look on hate websites, unless they're pretending to be civilised and going with full terms, they'll refer to trans people (mainly trans women) as "trannies". Hate groups recognise it as derogatory.
I can't comment on the opinion of the two trans people you talked to, but if you go into a trans space and ask their opinion on "tranny", most will agree it's a slur. Some might say it's okay to say, but they are probably trying to reclaim the word, rather than denying its current status as a slur.
And ultimately it's that last point that is most important, since it's trans people who get to decide what is offensive to trans people, cis people don't get that decision.
Also: The Sun article I mention was clearly using "tranny" as a way of emphasising the weirdness of the story (and it was a weird story, something about a bank robber who defrauded a bank by pretending to be an old woman). This others trans people, since it reinforces the idea that cis people should look at them as freaks and curiosities, or laugh at them for being different.