TKretts3 said:
Windwaker, Mario Sunshine, and Resident Evil 4 are underrated? News to me.
What I would really suggest is one of my favourite games of all time, yet one that isn't all that known about. It's Peter Jackson's King Kong, the video game. When it first came out I played it and automatically loved it. Going on a 1950's adventure to a lost, unknown, forsaken island frozen in time where everything around you is trying to kill you. AND THE V-REXS. Too many games now a days make the player some uber-badass that nothing can stop. What I like about King Kong is that it has the guts to throw in an enemy that the player is helpless against. An enemy which chases the player around every corner, yet the player can never overcome.
The OP was making the point that those
aren't underrated, but wants suggestions for games to play besides ones that come so obviously recommended. And speaking of which, I love you forever for bringing up
King Kong, which is my favorite movie tie-in game of all time (including even
Spider-Man 2) for its overall presentation and tense, immersive survival-action gameplay. Be on the lookout for a thread by me concerning it within the next day or two, thanks to you helpfully jump-starting my memory.
As for my own suggestions,
Ultimate Spider-Man provides a similar experience to
Spider-Man 2 (which is also on the Gamecube, if it counts as underrated) and a very comic book-like visual style,
Godzilla: Destroy All Monsters Melee probably does a better job of putting the player into the shoes of a giant monster than any other game and is an enjoyable fighting game in its own right, the first two
Lego Star Wars games are always good for anything from relaxation to comedy to involved secret-hunting, I've spent more time messing around in
Tony Hawk's American Wasteland than I can count, the
Resident Evil remake breeds a wonderful sense of constant apprehension and is easily one of the best-presented games on the system, the
Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King adaption is an extremely good hack-and-slasher with a whole lot of replayability thanks to its varied characters and surprisingly rewarding progression system, and
The Lord of the Rings: The Third Age, despite thoroughly squandering the story opportunities offered by its premise (especially after the first three or four levels), is immensely satisfying thanks to its
Final Fantasy X-esque combat system and so-fun-it-needs-to-be-its-own-campaign Evil Mode.
Man, this thread really reminds me of how much I miss the Gamecube...