If you could experience one game for the first time again.

[pookie101]

A few that have already been mentioned. Either Morrowind so I can experience that sense of wonder that I've rarely experienced since. Or Danganronpa, because I loved them but I see little value in replaying a murder mystery story.

life is strange.. my favourite game of all time

That was the first one that sprang to mind for me. I played the entire thing a couple of weeks ago and loved it. But it did leave me an emotional wreck and I don't think I'd want to put myself through that again.

i know what you mean. it had some really strong gut punch moments but still its my choice

 

[Hieronymusgoa]

Mass Effect 1-3 which I even liked with the original ending, but even more with the DLC-ending

Yeah, Secret of Mana, too.

 

[sky pies]

Vanilla WoW :'( though i'd like to unconsciously, intuitively know then what I know now about playing it.

 

[Rubblemaker]

Max Payne. Played it on launch day. I loved it so much the first time I played it that I finished it in one weekend, then immediately went back to the beginning and played it all the way through again. Ahhhh, the good old days of having no responsibilities *looks forlornly at wedding ring and pictures of toddler and gets teary eyed?...

 

[Rack]

I'd have to go with Telltale's The Walking Dead Season One.

I was going to say TWD S1 but then I realised the flaw. See if I forgot S1 I still couldn't replay it because my memories of S2 would still spoil too much of the important points. Similarly Portal 2 stops me replaying Portal again and getting the full effect.

I'm probably going to go with Brutal Legend. I loved that game, the story is a major part of it and there's nothing to spoil replaying it.

 

[Foolery]

Another vote for Wind Waker. That game is goddamn magical. Majora's Mask makes a close second though. I love my Zelda games.