Hey as as been said by others, comedy is subjective. I love Father Ted, all of it, and there are people who don't. Same with Monty Python, or indeed any show.MHR said:Listen. The second clip in the church has a fair bit of context to go with it.Alfador_VII said:Ok, I watched both of these clips.
Are there jokes in them?
I just never got this show. It has good actors and great writers, and I'm into computers. I just can't find the humour.
During the episode they visit one of those stupid gimmick quiz websites that tells the person when and what time they're going to die. Coincidentally, Roy and Moss had earlier in the day worked on overclocking the cellphone's vibrate setting up to 11. Roy was looking at the clock just realizing his deadline had passed when suddenly the phone goes off and startles him into thinking he's really dying.
That is comedy gold and if you don't think so then you are a sorry person and I have no desire to speak to you further.
And the whole show has got to be the consistently funniest I've ever seen. Nothing else I can think of off the top of my head beats it.
I think the real issue here is context, most of the IT Crowd humour is brought on from running gags throughout the episode that you really have to see the build up to enjoy (Like when Jen Moss and Roy go to the Theatre to see a film, and Jen walks into the bar after the show to find Roy in a wheelchair getting fawned over, turns to the barman to order some alcohol and discovers Moss serving drinks - As an individual scene not that funny, but in the context of the run up to it, I found it absolutely hilarious)Blood Brain Barrier said:That's a worry then. Who laughs that much at this stuff? What the hell are the live audience smoking? I want some.Carsus Tyrell said:I'm not gonna argue humour, subjective and all that jazz, but there's no canned laughter. IT Crowd is filmed live.Blood Brain Barrier said:There is none. I don't think I've seen a worse attempt at comedy than this show. It's not only not funny, it's annoying. The worst thing is the canned laughter after every line.Alfador_VII said:Ok, I watched both of these clips.
Are there jokes in them?
I just never got this show. It has good actors and great writers, and I'm into computers. I just can't find the humour.
Humour might be subjective, but objectively, cramming as many jokes and one-liners into the shortest time possible is bad and monotonous for the viewer. That's all the new comedies seem to be able to do. Is it too much to ask for a few minutes of plot development between the hilarity? Or does the audience suddenly fall asleep without laughing every 5 seconds?
Youtube code doesn't work here.bak00777 said:my favorite is the bomb defusing robot scene, from when Moss and Roy play hookie
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/Uh64nPT7JWk" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen>
Kathrine Parkinson got pregnant and quit to go take care of that. They offered to delay filming and she turned it down. Everyone else went to do their own things, and by the time Kathrine Parkinson was up for it again, everyone else was knee deep in their own stuff.jackdeesface said:In fairness thats been due to the actors having other commitments. Ayoade doing (crap) movies and directing. O'Dowd doing movies and I believe is in a series on Sky 1 and Kathrine Parkinson is/was on Doc Martin and filming maltersers adverts.
...so varying levels of busy I suppose.
Well there's a huge number of fans who would disagree with you on that. Truthfully I can see how you'd need the right kind of sense of humour to fully enjoy the show as with anything by Graham Linehan but the long and short of it is that a lot more people found it funny than didn't. No one's forcing you to watch it and you're only asking for trouble coming on a thread clearly aimed at fans just to complain about the show.Blood Brain Barrier said:There is none. I don't think I've seen a worse attempt at comedy than this show. It's not only not funny, it's annoying. The worst thing is the canned laughter after every line.Alfador_VII said:Ok, I watched both of these clips.
Are there jokes in them?
I just never got this show. It has good actors and great writers, and I'm into computers. I just can't find the humour.
I haven't seen any of that stuff so probably the latter. I heard a lot of people talking about IT Crowd saying it was the best thing ever so I decided to watch it. Even accounting for taste, "best comedy show ever" suggested to me it was up there with Fawlty Towers, South Park, Monty Python, Seinfeld.Silvanus said:You must've never seen Two and a Half Men, then. Or The Big Bang Theory. Or, actually, anything by Chuck Lorre, or any American remake of a British comedy (the Office, the Inbetweeners).Blood Brain Barrier said:I don't think I've seen a worse attempt at comedy than this show.
Must've never seen anything by Aaron Seltzer & Jason Friedberg... or a good number of Will Ferrell movies that came on the coat-tails of Anchorman, such as Step Brothers.
You're either very inexperienced with comedy, or you've managed to only see stuff of great quality!
The laughter is live. The blooper reels for the show actually have several instances where they have to redo a scene because someone in the audience accidentally blurts something out in the middle of there laughter, which makes the cast start busting out laughing.piinyouri said:Canned laughter? Is it? I never honestly could tell. It doesn't bother me though regardless. I'd be laughing every other line regardless of whether the audience was or not.
I only got that for the female cast member, but to be fair she's shown as being a pretty rotten person from the beginning. Roy can be pretty bad with the leching, but he never reaches anyone is Sunny's crew.piinyouri said:The show kind of turns into a lighter, geekier version of Always Sunny In Philidelphia as it progresses though. They aren't quite the level of despisable human beings as Dee, Dennis, Frank and Charlie are, but they sure seem to try as the series goes on.
True, true, it's mostly Jen who get's really petty and insecure, but Roy seems to quite enjoy making her uncomfortable later on and even Moss get's a bit weird.AccursedTheory said:I only got that for the female cast member, but to be fair she's shown as being a pretty rotten person from the beginning. Roy can be pretty bad with the leching, but he never reaches anyone is Sunny's crew.
I'm actually surprised you could compare the two. The people in Sunny are beyond terrible - They're the worst people ever to live that haven't murdered someone (Yet).
Anybody who finds that funny has never had the displeasure of trying to fix a computer for someone who is a complete fucking moron. Personally it just kinda makes me want to get drunk before the repressed memories come back.MHR said:This is the best and quintessential part of the IT crowd.
I found that my experiences fixing computers made this more hilarious.major_chaos said:Anybody who finds that funny has never had the displeasure of trying to fix a computer for someone who is a complete fucking moron. Personally it just kinda makes me want to get drunk before the repressed memories come back.MHR said:This is the best and quintessential part of the IT crowd.
OT: Hallelujah and praise jebuz its finally ending. Seriously, I know comedy is subjective and its all about taste and yada yada yada, but IT crowd stands out because of the nasty combo of being immensely popular and (IMO) incredibly annoying. I mean the very first clip in the thread just kinda made me want to punch the guy for managing to be a massive dickhead and unbelievably stupid at the same time.
Well, that just shows how subjective humour is. Whilst I know others love it, I've never liked Fawlty Towers, it just seems to be John Cleese getting angry at things. Personally I find the IT crowd much more enjoyable.Blood Brain Barrier said:I haven't seen any of that stuff so probably the latter. I heard a lot of people talking about IT Crowd saying it was the best thing ever so I decided to watch it. Even accounting for taste, "best comedy show ever" suggested to me it was up there with Fawlty Towers, South Park, Monty Python, Seinfeld.Silvanus said:You must've never seen Two and a Half Men, then. Or The Big Bang Theory. Or, actually, anything by Chuck Lorre, or any American remake of a British comedy (the Office, the Inbetweeners).Blood Brain Barrier said:I don't think I've seen a worse attempt at comedy than this show.
Must've never seen anything by Aaron Seltzer & Jason Friedberg... or a good number of Will Ferrell movies that came on the coat-tails of Anchorman, such as Step Brothers.
You're either very inexperienced with comedy, or you've managed to only see stuff of great quality!