It's 1944. You are allowed to take 4 characters with you on a mission to stop the Nazis.

[RaNDM G]

Captain Price,
B.J. Blazkowicz,
Wojtek the Fighting Bear,
Ronald Speirs.

They formed the most awesome Bear Cavalry the world would ever see.

 

[xthetenth]

Real people team (which for a bonus could actually have been assembled):

Chesty Puller
Dan Daly
Jack Churchill
Smedley Butler

Sure with two officers it's rather heavy on command, but if anything goes wrong they can build a little fort out of all their medals and with three of the most hardcore US marines ever and Jack Churchill, I'm pretty sure they can kill nazis just by their presence. Seriously though, they have 4 medals of honor and enough navy crosses to use them as shurikens, they can't not lose. Also, I just learned that Chesty Puller is basically the USMC's Chuck Norris, so he might be ruled out under the no gods clause. And he's the American in the group without two medals of honor.

Fictional character team:
Caiphas Cain, HERO OF THE IMPERIUM
Gunner Jurgen and his trusty meltagun, the real hero of the cain books (the gun, although Jurgen's pretty damn handy himself)
Michael Weston to keep the team sane and deal with the half of Cain's bad luck that goes to the team.
Commander Shepard (soldier one) to soak the damage with all that lovely near invincibility from immunity.

 

[The Warden]

I'd take Dad from Fallout 3, Dog from HL2, Atton Rand from TSL, and the main character from Fable 2.
Why?
BECAUSE NONE OF THEM WILL JUST FUCKING DIE.
I mean, srsly, Dad's essential, Dog just won't fucking die, Atton gets knocked unconcious or whatever you call it and he has the ability to get back up as long as he isn't the last standing, and the main character from Fable 2 also gets only knocked unconscious.
Come to think of it, why am I going as well?
These guys can handle it, hell, why don't we just send one of them in? I can guarantee that any one of these could do it with ease all alone.

 

[Doc Shaftoe]

Joseph Stalin, Winston Churchill, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, and Harry S. Truman.
I don't mess with proven victories.

-fixed.

(and this)

 

[Contun]

America's modern day military.

And a flock of Pterodactyls.

 

[slowpoke999]

I'd probably just take the four most overpowered characters from Western cartoons and Anime

 

[TheOnceandFutureKing]

Shaun Connery, Vin Diesel, Deadpool, Abraham Lincoln

 

[jimduckie]

agent 47 , sam fisher ,solid snake , captain quark ( need someone to laugh at)

 

[berault]

Indiana Jones (Fighting Nazis is kind of his thing)
Wolverine (The guy is essentially bullet proof)
Nathanial Drake (Drake kills more baddies in an afternoon then I can count)
Ezio Auditore Da Firenzi (Self-explanatory)

 

[Pigeon_Grenade]

hmmm Hard Choice

though is have to Choose 4 Space marines for That One,

Bjorn the Fell Handed( http://wh40k.lexicanum.com/wiki/Bjorn_the_Fell-Handed )
Helbrecht( http://wh40k.lexicanum.com/wiki/Helbrecht )
Davian Thule( http://wh40k.lexicanum.com/wiki/Davian_Thule )
Marneus Augustus Calgar( http://wh40k.lexicanum.com/wiki/Marneus_Calgar )

i find the idea of Space Marines Slaying Nazis Entertaining

 

[Discord]

4 random pokemon

or Marcus, Dom, Cole and Baird

 

[Lord of Maggots]

Ronald Reagan (because "Reagan SMASH")


Tom, Mark, and Travis from blink 182 to play some music while i watch Reagan FSU.

 

[Christemo]

id rather go stop America from taking all the glory and let the ruskies do it.

to stop team Uncle Sam, id have:

-Captain Falcon
-Chuck Norris
-Mr. T and his mohawk nades.
-Abraham Lincoln in a ninja suit with a laser katana.

 

[Christemo]

America's modern day military.

And a flock of Pterodactyls.

that reminds me of Dino D-day, a new WW2 game coming this year where the nazis have DINOSAURS.

RUUUUUUUN, IZ GOZILLA!!

 

[AWAR]

Stalin, Churchil, Captain Price and David Bowie.