Korean Game Addiction Treatment Looks Pretty Extreme

SteewpidZombie

New member
Dec 31, 2010
545
0
0
Well it's how THEY deal with the problem. You can't really treat any addiction, once your addicted to ANYTHING then it will always be apart of your life. Maybe this method will work, maybe not. But the outcome will help people see whether or not such practices can actually 'cure' someone of a videogame addiction. In S.Korea it seems to actually be a valid concern after the large number of teens and people that are in fact becoming legal addicts to something that 90% of us 'Western' gamers would consider a part time hobby.

(My phrase 'Western' includes Europe, United States, Canada. Because those are where the majority of casual or regular gamers are from. Not to say that other countries are excluded at all)
 

CD-R

New member
Mar 1, 2009
1,355
0
0
Scrythe said:
So how long 'till they adopt something similar in the States?

Oh wait, they call it "rehab" here, and it's as effective as a wet paper bag in the middle of the ocean.
No it's called military school. They also have those boot camps that day time talk show hosts send troubled kids too.
 

Therumancer

Citation Needed
Nov 28, 2007
9,909
0
0
The big complaint here actually seems to be kids acting like kids. I can see the issue in a country where the idea of leisure time, technology, and similar things are new. A culture used to the ideal of back breaking labour as soon as one is physically capable of it, doubtlessly finds something decadent in kids spending a lot of time playing video games, despite that this is what they arguably worked for in improving their standard of living. What's more while someone who had never had access to an educational system values that kind of thing highly, once educational systems become standardized and taken for granted, those who come up with them see the situation a lot differantly. This is especially true when it comes to skills that even kids realize they are likely to never use, and/or competitive systems where the people who are going to go somewhere are identified rather quickly and everyone else is just degrees of average. The recognized inabillity to succeed or achieve anything of note is what creates the entire "slacker" mindset. A lot of societies very much want to put kids through a bunch of loops so they can make the pretensions that they can go somewhere and things haven't already been decided, for their own conscience more than the kids. People do catch on to this, and realizing there is nothing to motivate them and refuse to jump through hoops. The ironic thing is that for all comments about getting kids to stop playing video games and put more effort into schoolwork (in all countries), it probably really doesn't matter beyond the age of like 12 or 13 other than basic skills due to the elite and geniuses having been selected. While it makes a conveinent scapegoat to avoid addressing societal problems (video games are the current boogieman, something is always used for this) like this, the amount of time spent blowing off schoolwork for games or whatever isn't going to make a differance for the average person who will never use 99% of what they learn, and isn't going to have any more options simply because nobody stamped "Genius" on their record. Yes I'm a cynic.

At any rate, South Korea is what I see as being a "Neo Barbarian" country even if some people resent that term. The term meaning a backwards culture, trying to progress, and frequently in possession of technology in excess of the societal development to deal with it. While insulting to some,I think it's a label that needs to be used more often, especially as it can help in recognizing issues and understanding what your seeing. Just a few decades ago Korea was (during war time) a nation where little boys were sent to work as soon as they could, and little girls were as often as not prostituted by their parents as soon as they could physically handle it. There are plenty of shocking stories about the culture from back when we were fighting a war down there, and most of it was pretty much par for the course in second and third world countries. Korea was one of the many nations that inspired video "shockographies" like the "Shocking Asia" series and so on, because it was both a culture shock and also relatively safe to visit for a long time. It's not surprisng that with such rapid progress technologically and socially, that your seeing a whole "correct the behavior with torture" attitude here... and that's what it pretty much is, the pictures go well beyond what you'd see in an American or European "military school" (or any that I am aware of) or even "boot camp" type detoxication and deprogramming (for people rescued from cults) programs. Not to mention that it's all over a non-issue, that pretty much exists due to the culture becoming culture-shocked with itself over a generation due to rapid progress.
 

Cid Silverwing

Paladin of The Light
Jul 27, 2008
3,134
0
0
Ashsaver said:
Another sign of parents failure:dump their problem on to somebody else's lap
This.

Even Asia seems to have soccer moms out the ass. Is there no end to the irresponsibility virus?
 

lacktheknack

Je suis joined jewels.
Jan 19, 2009
19,316
0
0
I can't condemn these as being cruel, interestingly enough. It's certainly less cruel than letting your child think that life is all video games and nothing else.
 

Nincompoop

New member
May 24, 2009
1,035
0
0
Scrythe said:
... as effective as a wet paper bag in the middle of the ocean.
Effective in what way? If the sole purpose is being wet and papery, then it's pretty damn effective. And it does hold water.
__
OT: That kid in the camp sounded oddly mind-controlled by the situation. Or he's just playing nice to get out of the camp and finally get his human paladin to level 85.
 

gphjr14

New member
Aug 20, 2010
868
0
0
Considering their neighbors to the north are constantly thinking of ways to piss the world off and someday invade the south I'd want my youth to be in better shape instead of dying from fatigue from videogames. But in the end the parents should be out their too since they're enablers.
 

Druyn

New member
May 6, 2010
554
0
0
AK47Marine said:
Shit it's just getting sent to military school, happens all the time in the states

South Korea requires mandatory military service any way, so this will just give them a leg up when they head to real boot camp.

Edit: That said this almost seems like an excuse to avoid parenting, a parent should be able to instill discipline in their children themselves. If they really are heading off on the wrong track (joining a gang, etc) then this type of punishment and social reform would be quite valuable and more useful then Juvi
Yeah, I dont see the big deal. Not with the training, Im sure the camp is hard considering its a boot camp, and I sure as hell wouldnt want to do it, but I mean the concept. Really, happens all the time over here, and sometimes if the parents cant or wont do it, the kids need a push in th eright direction.
 

Nouw

New member
Mar 18, 2009
15,615
0
0
Holy shit I'm thankful I'm in NZ! And I thought they couldn't get harsher >.>

But it's not that bad, military service is compulsory over there. Nevertheless, the parents should fix the 'problem' by their self.
[sub]But I don't know squat about that aspect of culture over there so the first 2 sentences are the ones you can quote on.[/sub]
 

Infernoshadow211

New member
Nov 18, 2009
105
0
0
Jumplion said:
While I am tempted to pass this off as "It's a different culture, different societies, etc...", I'd have to say that it's a bit extreme.
I thought we had boot camp in the states.
 

kannibus

New member
Sep 21, 2009
989
0
0
Reminds me of boot camp for sure. Fun times. Except that I could go out and get HAMMERED on weekends.

Ugh, early Monday Morning "Beat the Booze Out PT" was NOT nice.
 

Aethren

New member
Jun 6, 2009
1,063
0
0
Finally they do something right over there.

Now I just wish America would have mandatory boot camp, maybe then our kids wouldn't be such spoiled f***tards.

For both genders of course, gotta have equality.
 

TimeLord

For the Emperor!
Legacy
Aug 15, 2008
7,508
3
43
dalek sec said:
I'm wondering just how effective these camps really are in the long run...
I would think that they would make an excellent deterrent! If one of my mates came back from a camp for videogame addiction with tales like that Korean camp then I would cut down my videogame usage!
 

DarthFennec

New member
May 27, 2010
1,154
0
0
"They even become violent and disrespect the older."
Huh, I wonder why. Can't have anything to do with the older forcing them to make half naked snow angels, could it?
 

milkkart

New member
Dec 27, 2008
172
0
0
theres gonna be some kids who get sent there who need some help, though i doubt military training is the kind they need (gomer pyle springs to mind), but the majority are probably your typical teenage. likes video games, hates school work, is pissed off at parents due to being all fucked up on hormones. sending them to some camp is just gonna make them hate their parents even more.

and iirc there have been 16 deaths ever due to gaming addiction in korea, mostly adults. how many kids in america get all angsty and kill themselves each year? or do a 100mph into another car while driving and smear themselves across the tarmac.

maybe im just stereotyping but this seems like a kneejerk reaction by parents and authorities to korean kids absorbing typical western teenage attitudes and rejecting the study hard, go to college, get a career lifestyle their parents had and want them to have.
 

Jumplion

New member
Mar 10, 2008
7,873
0
0
Infernoshadow211 said:
Jumplion said:
While I am tempted to pass this off as "It's a different culture, different societies, etc...", I'd have to say that it's a bit extreme.
I thought we had boot camp in the states.
I'm pretty sure we do, but I'm also pretty sure we reserve those for the really tough to handle delinquent kids, not kids who play a bit too much Starcraft or kids who are a little clingy to their parents. But, like I said, it's mainly a different culture, and Starcraft is a huge problem there.
 

Death God

New member
Jul 6, 2010
1,754
0
0
I would never let myself have a video game addiction. Let alone an addiction so strong that I get sent to a military camp. No game is worth harsh conditions and brutal workouts.
 

milkkart

New member
Dec 27, 2008
172
0
0
Death God said:
I would never let myself have a video game addiction. Let alone an addiction so strong that I get sent to a military camp. No game is worth harsh conditions and brutal workouts.
crack totally is though.