Gorrath said:
I don't get the whole, "But he's a sucky actor," stuff. By what measure is he not a good actor? Sure he wasn't any good when he was a kid but he's grown quite a lot since Titanic. Is this just an, "everyone loves to hate," kind of thing or do people actually have reasons why they say he's shit? He's crap compared to whom exactly? He's sure as shit better than a fair few who have won best actor. Jane Fonda has two for god's sake. I'm not saying he's the greatest; I'll take Tom hardy over him any day, but the guy's got good enough chops to deserve an Oscar.
I can only speak for myself when I say his acting method is just being loud and annoyed, and scowling a lot. That's it. Unlike other great actors who can completely disappear into a role, like Jennifer Jason Leigh as Daisy Domergue in
Hateful Eight, with Leo the character usually just disappears into him. It's always Leo forcefully trying to act like someone, typically by way of screaming.
There are far worse actors than Leo, but I don't think that's enough to warrant an Oscar. I'd place the guy at the same level as Matt Damon and Brad Pitt; Okay actor, but nothing more than that.