Bat Vader said:
Fox12 said:
Bat Vader said:
I would love to see a five way fight between Jaime Lannister, Barristan Selmy, Arthur Dayne, Aragorn, and Geralt of Rivia. All five are considered to be the best of the best in their respective fictions.
Aragorn, easily. He's got 80+ years of fighting experience in 20 year old body. Basically, more experience then Barristan in a body that's more fit then Jaime. Besides, we haven't seen them do much. Mostly we just hear about how great they are. Geralt may be a tougher fight, depending on how strong he is. I've only read a few of the Witcher books. I vaguely remember him taking a potion that let him fight for, like, three days, but Aragorn can basically do that anyway, because of his Dunedain blood, while Geralt presumably wouldn't be able to rely on curatives or potions. Unless he has some trick I'm unaware of (which is entirely possible) I would give it to Aragorn. It actually annoyed me that Martin said Jaime could take Aragorn in a fight. Not anything against Jaime, of course, Aragorn is past peak human.
Gandalf the Grey (book) vs Zodd the Immortal
Gandalf the White (book) vs Skull Knight/God Hand.
Berserker Guts vs Knight Artorias (before he went coo coo for coa coa puffs)
Jar Jar Binks vs. Snarf Snarf
Geralt is about 100 or so and he is considered one of the best if not the best swordsman in the world. I could see him and Aragorn having an epic fight. Even though Selmy is older I could see him giving Aragorn some trouble. I feel they would equally respect one another because of their honor.
Jaime Lannister vs Boromir would be a good fight.
Wow, really? Geralt may be able to take the fight then, that's pretty impressive. In terms of skill, I thing Selmy would probably be comparable to Aragorn or Geralt. He may even be better if they were on a more even fighting ground. A 25 year old Selmy, for instance, could possibly take a 25 year old Aragorn. The main advantage for Aragorn and Geralt, I think, would simply be their skill matched with their strength, vigor, and age. It wouldn't really be fair to poor Selmy, since he's the most human of the characters, but I think he'd put in a good fight, at the very least.
I could possibly see Jaime taking Boromir. Based on the books, Boromir would probably be stronger, but Jaime could possibly be more fluent with a sword, and would probably be much faster. It could go either way, honestly.
Khal Drogo vs Lurtz would be an amusing fight. No finesse, just raw carnage.