I've re-watched the first 2 recently, and noticed some things. Firstly, I don't want an extended edition of the third movie, as the epilogue alone is enough to make the length of that film damned near unbearable. Second, while
The Two Towers used to be my favorite, I now favor
Fellowship. The battle for Helm's Deep that so defines
Towers has simply not held up as well over time as I would have thought. Sure, it's larger scale than any other fight in the trilogy, but it's not as well pulled off in my opinion, and it doesn't carry the same emotional weight, and isn't as fun to watch, as the horseback chase sequence or the cave troll/Balrog section of
Fellowship.
And I still want to know how Steven Tyler's genes could possibly produce this: