Except I didn't ask if you wanted to eat at the restaurant again (play the ME series again), I asked if you thought the steak was good (the games prior to the ending), which in your analogy, you said it was "really good." You are mixing up aspects of the dinner (franchise) in the criticism. Now, I'm not saying a lot of people don't think like this, but it's unfair to your metaphorical steak (and the chef who cooked it, and possibly didn't have anything to do with the dessert) to say it's now the worst piece of cooked meat you ever ate, due to something entirely unrelated to it.The terrible ending does leave a bad impression regardless and has definitely ruined any motivation I had for starting a new character. Yeah sure there's a lot of fun middle moments, but in the end they all culminate in pushing one of three buttons in the ending-o-matron. For many people, how something ends tends does affect the general feel for what happened before. I could have the best meal at a place, but if I find a cockroach in my dessert - well I'm not going back just because their steak was really good.
Though the other half for me is that ME1 has aged about as well as milk when it comes to gameplay systems, and I don't think I have it in me to put up with that. While I like to joke about the Mako after the fact, good lord I don't want to explore those planets again.
Last edited: