Sorry about the thread necro, but I think I have a fairly good excuse.
Jim, because of this video, I went out and bought Silent Hill Revelation. I hadn't seen it (I'm not sure why - just never got around to it) but this review made me want to see it.
So I bought it. Watched it. LOVED IT.
I am willing to call this one of the best three video game movies I have ever seen in my life.
So thank you, Jim, for getting me to watch this. I found the first Silent Hill movie disappointing, but his movie entirely made up for it. Well... almost entirely. The first movie is still pretty meh.
JudgeGame said:
I never tire of saying Heather is my favourite character in video game fiction and I give this movie the pass because they practically nailed her. Her particular blend of anger, fear and humour is not easy to pull off twice and they did.
This.
Well, not the favorite character of all time, but I do like her, and one thing this movie did perfectly was Heather's character. She is spot on.
One other thing. On the issue of Pyramid Head - the stuff with Pyramid Head makes much more sense once you realize that he ISN'T PYRAMID HEAD. He's Valtiel in a Pyramid Head outfit.
Valtiel is the named monster in Silent Hill 3 who turns valves and cranks - like the one on the carousel - and who at one point defends Heather from a female monster - like the battle at the end of the movie.
Sound familiar?
They just reskinned (pun intended) Valtiel as Pyramid Head for marketing purposes.
Actually, Valtiel being the real identity of Pyramid Head in the movies makes the first film retroactively make more sense. It doesn't make it any better, but it makes more sense.