pure.Wasted said:
I actually feel pretty crappy about it, yeah. And I'm sure I'm not alone, otherwise big screens wouldn't... really... be a thing. You wouldn't really suggest that watching TDKR in theaters and at home is the same experience, would you? There's a reason people paid extra on top of that to watch it in IMAX.
Playing a game that's going out of its way to wow you on a small screen just seems like a disservice. In fact, this strikes me so common sensical, I really don't understand how PC gamers can just shrug consoles away. I'm sure pixel density helps (I didn't know that! But it makes sense, of course) but you're still basically listening to a cool new album without headphones... don't you think?
I said it earlier and I'll say it again, screen size is irrelevant because a 50" TV and a 23" monitor are running at exactly the same resolution (1080p), both screens "fill" your vision because you are sitting proportionately the same distance away from them.
In fact I would say a 23" monitor viewed from 2 feet away fills far more of your vision than a 50" plasma viewed from 3-4 meters away - this is one of the crucial reasons behind why most PC gamers demand a 90-degree Field of View (FoV) enabled in PC ports as opposed to the 55-60 degree FoV that consoles use...but that's another story for another time.
Coming back to pixel density, monitors do a wonderful job of displaying the finer details - and I think you'll agree that often beauty is all about the finer details. Higher-grade IPS/PLS monitors can also display vibrant accurate colors and broad viewing angles which most TV's lack, also there are 120hz monitors which provide insane smoothness and response times (no ghosting/tearing issues) which TV's can't hope to reach.
Combine this with what I also said earlier about convenience and practicality. Remember that gaming is not all people do on computers - we do a lot of web browsing, work stuff, etc and those tasks would be nothing short of retarded to do on a big TV screen. It's easy for people to forget that a gaming computer can do a hell of lot more than just gaming. Browsing porn would also not be smart to do in the living roo--wait, I meant browsing Escapist. Gaming is a side-thing for PC users, in fact quite a few PC gamers have 2 screens (one running a game, one for web browsing).
Secondly mice/keyboards also need stable platforms and don't exactly have super-long cable lengths like console controllers. Also most people can't place a 50" TV on their computer desk in fear of it falling over, or their eyeballs melting due to sitting 2 feet away from such a giant screen.
You get the idea by this point I hope?