i will question and mock you for judging them on one gameJ Tyran said:If you went to a cinema and spent £12 on a ticket to watch a film and the film was the weirdest garbage you have ever seen would you in all honestly go and watch another one by that filmmaker and director etc again? Answer that honestly and not answer in defense of a genre or developer you like because that isn't what I asked. If you like this stuff you like it and I wont question that or mock you for liking it but I would rather avoid playing anything by them ever again.Tony2077 said:try one the the real jrpgs they've made or published before you judge themJ Tyran said:Judging by the games they make nothing of value will be lost, I was tricked into trying one of them once. They had "Catherine" on PS+ for ages advertised as an RPG, I thought "you know what as its free I will give it a go, maybe I will change my mind about JRPGs if I try a newer one", what a mistake that was. A 10GB download later and what did I get?
Some sort of weird softcore porn girlfriend simulator.
Way to confirm my bias about a genre Index Holdings.
Good analogy!Mcoffey said:If the movie was an experiment by the director to do something different from their usual fair (Which Catherine was), sure. It's not reflective of their usual body of work.J Tyran said:-SNIP-
If you went to a cinema and spent £12 on a ticket to watch a film and the film was the weirdest garbage you have ever seen would you in all honestly go and watch another one by that filmmaker and director etc again? Answer that honestly and not answer in defense of a genre or developer you like because that isn't what I asked. If you like this stuff you like it and I wont question that or mock you for liking it but I would rather avoid playing anything by them ever again.
I hate the Transformers films, but I put that aside and saw Michael Bay's Pain and Gain. Fantastic movie.
J Tyran said:If you went to a cinema and spent £12 on a ticket...
Nah, you couldn't be that entitled. We'll let that go. Let's take another look at what's going on here.J Tyran said:..."you know what as its free I will give it a go...
Yeah I'm pretty sure they'll be fine. I'm actually surprised they had a parent company at all; this is something I didn't know about, and Atlus is one of my favorite publishers right now.Klonoa Prower said:I'm fairly sure Atlus in Japan operates a lot differently than in America. After all, they're by and far, one of the biggest developers in that country with a massive fanbase behind them. I'm pretty sure, that whoever does buy them in the end will be more than content to just sit back and have them make them money.
If you don't want to trust their games that's fine, but is that really a good reason? Persona 3 and 4 are probably some of my favorite games of all time, they don't seem to be you cup of tea so I won't push them on you but it'd be pretty sad if I was disappointed by one of their games and never tried them. Besides, I've enjoyed plenty of movies by directors that also made bad films. I saw the Village by M. Night Shammalalalam at a drive in and it was complete shit but later I saw Unbreakable by him and liked it. I also saw 2001: A Space Odyssey and thought was boring and confusing. That didn't stop me from later watching and enjoying the fuck out of The ShinningJ Tyran said:If you went to a cinema and spent £12 on a ticket to watch a film and the film was the weirdest garbage you have ever seen would you in all honestly go and watch another one by that filmmaker and director etc again? Answer that honestly and not answer in defense of a genre or developer you like because that isn't what I asked. If you like this stuff you like it and I wont question that or mock you for liking it but I would rather avoid playing anything by them ever again.
Yeah you got it for free so I don't think you have much room to complain, there are also plenty of reviews and people's opinions about it since it isn't a new release so some research probably would have helped, at a 10.1Gb download I would have checked exactly what I'm getting. Ok you didn't like, a lot of other people agree with you, but then there are other games by the same developer that A LOT of people say is a masterpiece. A studio won't have a masterpiece every time, especially when trying something new, sometimes they make a flop. It's not fair to judge the entire genre on 1 game and 1 developer.Salad Is Murder said:Okay, fair enough. I...wait, hold on a second...
J Tyran said:If you went to a cinema and spent £12 on a ticket...J Tyran said:..."you know what as its free I will give it a go...
This is very interesting to consider and may be a good move for them if they can.Quiotu said:Yeah I'm pretty sure they'll be fine. I'm actually surprised they had a parent company at all; this is something I didn't know about, and Atlus is one of my favorite publishers right now.
Which leads me to ask a question... if Atlus is doing really well even if Index isn't, could Atlus potentially buy their market share back from Index and go completely independent? Atlus seems to know what they're doing when it comes to marketing their games, and they're one of the more beloved mid-tier publishers out there. Atlus being free to do whatever the hell they want without having a parent company to worry about might be the best thing ever for them.
well its not the states so hopefully we won't have to worry about any brainless judges screwing things up if it comes to a saleTisiphone1 said:As best I can tell, this appears to be a reorganization bankruptcy rather than a liquidation, so Atlus should be fine. They're releasing Dragon's Crown in Japan on schedule and intend to continue business as usual during the reorganization.
Even were it to become a liquidation, I've seen more than one site state that the gaming division is the company's most valuable asset and would be expected to easily be bought. Not worried!
I feel free to mock you for liking the kind of rubbish this developer makes, thank god there wont be any more of it.Tony2077 said:i will question and mock you for judging them on one game
Lets answer this step by step,Salad Is Murder said:Okay, fair enough. I...wait, hold on a second...
J Tyran said:If you went to a cinema and spent £12 on a ticket...Nah, you couldn't be that entitled. We'll let that go. Let's take another look at what's going on here.J Tyran said:..."you know what as its free I will give it a go...
1) I like movies.
2) I hear a new movie by Flufflebutt Honeypore is coming out, possibly his Honeypore'ist yet.
3) I've never seen a movie by this director but everyone who has ever seen any of its movies anywhere says they're fantastic. OVERWHELMING WORD OF MOUTH AND FEEDBACK WORLDWIDE CORROBORATES THIS POINT.
4) To be honest, I didn't catch the movie when it first came out...truth to be told I didn't catch it until about two years later on Cinemax.
5) It didn't live up to my expectations, in fact, it was much more different than I was used to. Not at all like the other movies I'd ever seen; I didn't like it.
6) End result: I have decided that the only reasonable response to this scenario I find myself in is to not only hate the newly knighted Sir F. Honeypore, but every other one of his creations despite never having watched them, and to actively cheer the financial troubles of the studio that helps to fund his projects.
Yeah, that seems reasonable. Carry on, then.
That would be great! However, I'm banking on Square making the highest bid, should it come to a sale.IllumInaTIma said:This would be a perfect opportunity for Sony to fuel up their PR train even more. Swoop in, buy Atlus, and make their games exclusive to PlayStation. Boom! Everyone wins. Okay, almost everyone. But it is still better than letting that amazing company die!