I suppose we can let point 3 alone now (even if you kinda missed the point).Jezzy54 said:1. It's not because the baby seals are cute, it's that they're killed when they're the equivalent age of a child. At least let them see adulthood. Yeah, the fur's not the same then, but I really don't care.lacktheknack said:Three things:Jezzy54 said:Well, accent on "kinda". I'm not really saying they should die, but I do hate professional fur hunters. I can justify killing an animal to eat it, that's just part of nature. However, I take exception with killing baby animals if you can survive without doing so, and the fur industry as it is should not exist. The human race has, for the most part, gotten to the point where we don't need to take other animal's skin to survive, and so killing anything for fur in a first-world country like Canada is a selfish waste of animal life, and killing baby animals for that objective is doubly reprehensible. If someone kills growing animals for a living and to acquire a resource no buyer really needs, they are a terrible person and should GET ANOTHER JOB.lacktheknack said:Um, no? Seal hunters need money, and the seal hunt brings in a ton of money.Jezzy54 said:Well, baby seal hunters kinda deserve it.
Are you seriously basing an ethical decision on how CUTE something is?!
Are all Eskimos evil for eating seal?
Calves have bigger, wetter eyes than baby seals. Therefore, you must be evil for eating beef.
The list goes on.
1. They're animals. Baby animals are no better than the adult animal, the only major difference is that they're cuter. Killing a baby seal is exactly the same as killing an adult seal, unless cuteness is a factor for you.
2. No buyer needs them, but buyers will pay a LOT for them. Sorry, but we're in debt. We need cash. We'll take money where we can get it.
3. You find them a job. I dare you. (You clearly don't know the economic climate of the North West Territories and Nunavut...)
2. It's not like seal clubbing only happens during a recession. What about when the economy was just fine? That excuse only applies to times like these, when I'll admit it's a legitimate reason, but I'm betting that most seal clubbers who need their job to survive right now were already seal clubbers when jobs were easier to find.
3. Oh, crap, you dare me? Hell, now I've gotta go to the other side of the world and single-handedly destroy the seal fur industry because someone on the internet dared me. No. Somehow, I doubt most will change jobs even when the recession ends.
1. That's a bizarre stance. What, kill all the parents instead and let all the baby seals get eaten by bears, foxes and whales? Not only does this kill more seals overall, it wastes fur. I can't see any reason to not kill baby seals that isn't entirely emotionally driven.
2. No, really. The economy in the Territories is absolute crap. Even during "boom times", there's still not enough jobs for everyone. Of course, you wouldn't know this, being on the other side of the world and all.