Yeah, there's nothing in this scenario where pro gaming skills actually mean much, maybe said pro athletes/soldiers/drivers would benefit from pro gamers giving them a rundown of how the original games mechanics worked, or even working as an adviser over a radio to the people in the field, but video games in the 80's weren't exactly subtly complex, they were designed to be quickly picked up and played in short bursts without much instruction.tippy2k2 said:100% absolutely positively YES YES YES, give me the world class athlete over any of those guys.Lufia Erim said:Are you sure? I mean sure you COULD choose world class athelete, but they don't know the mechanics of these games. I'd pick the gamer for the sole purpose that, even if they aren't phsically fit, they have an idea of what they are suppose to be doing, and worst case scenerio, can find way around any physical limitation they have.tippy2k2 said:What I still don't get (and maybe the movie explains it but I sure as hell will never find out) is why would they choose these guys to do all the games?
I get that they were good at video games...but these aren't video games. They use video game mechanics but if I had to choose between Adam Sandler and a world class athlete to play Donkey Kong in real life to determine the fate of the world, I'm choosing the world class athlete over the guy who looks like he'd lose his breath climbing the first ladder. Being good at video games isn't going to get you to jump over that barrel...
It's kind like the first time you play a board game and aren't familiar with the rules. Unless you are really lucky, you're going to lose
(Note: I still have not and in all likeliness will never see Pixels, I am going off of the trailer for this):
Did PacMan teach Adam Sandler how to be a world class race car driver? Did Cenepede teach Josh Gad how to aim, reload, and fire a weapon? Did Donkey Kong teach Peter Dinklage how to jump over barrels?
I know we like to think games are a super awesome skill but seven year old tippy2k2 was playing Donkey Kong and PacMan and Centipede; video games are not a tough skill to learn. From the trailer, it looks like Dinklage was in jail and that had to have taken at least a few hours to get him out; I'm pretty sure you could have a few world class athletes figure out how Donkey Kong works in a few hours.
Hell, worst case scenario, there's bound to be a couple of professional race car drivers, marksmen from the Army, and...uh....anyone with more than a two foot vertical leap who is also a gamer, right?
Especially since these senarios don't even follow the original games all that closely, knowing how the different ghosts AI worked in Pacman doesn't help at all since the humans are playing the ghosts so they have no idea how pacman is going to act, knowing that power pellets make pacman able to eat ghosts isn't exactly a complex concept that would outweigh putting a professional driver behind the wheel of the ghost cars.
Even then, the movie seems to abandon following game rules as they can just blow up monsters with those strange four-barreled energy weapons. So the whole premise of needing professional gamers is abandoned in favor of Call of Duty style shoot-em-up mechanics. That might be where MovieBob's criticism of the main character eschewing his old school gaming skills for a modern attitude of, do whatever to survive, comes from. Not a terrible idea for a character arc, learning to sacrifice linear thinking and habit to save those around you and overcome unconventional problems, but it just kind of reinforces the pointlessness of needing professional gamers to do any of this.