Seems weak willed to me.jboking said:I think that is a bit of a stretch. I know plenty of people that believe in an afterlife where the morally right live in happiness. To me, this would seem to cause the person to try and be a good person, or at least guilt trip them into it. It would make a person who does good for his fellow man so he can reap the benefits. That's not really destructive, just helpful.Stalk3rchief said:That was sarcasm. If you believe in an afterlife that just makes you care less about your current life, making a potentially self destructive person. I just don't see how anyone can think that's a good thing.
*shrug*
And I agree. My point was that they are still being nice, not destructive.theultimateend said:Seems weak willed to me.jboking said:I think that is a bit of a stretch. I know plenty of people that believe in an afterlife where the morally right live in happiness. To me, this would seem to cause the person to try and be a good person, or at least guilt trip them into it. It would make a person who does good for his fellow man so he can reap the benefits. That's not really destructive, just helpful.Stalk3rchief said:That was sarcasm. If you believe in an afterlife that just makes you care less about your current life, making a potentially self destructive person. I just don't see how anyone can think that's a good thing.
*shrug*
I do nice things for people because I like the feeling of being nice. I don't need to be coerced into not being a ****. It is a bit disturbing to think that people need to be tricked into being nice.
But that is of course just my two cents.
I never argued for any religion, in fact, I never brought one up. So I see no need to compare it to optimism. However, I will say that most examples of how religion has done harm is the word being abused or misplaced. You may not realize it now, but misplaced optimism has done worlds of hurt. See: 2001-2004 - US gov attitude towards middle east conflict.I have seen no evidence to show that religion is any more beneficial than being optimistic, however there are centuries/millenia of evidence that show how religion (unlike optimism) can result in great wrongs.
A look at the AIDS epidemic in Africa is a fantastic quick current example. Telling folks that condoms cause aids and that they will cause one to, when they die, end up in eternal damnation is a truly terrible thing.
I am fully in support of optimism, I think people should try and look at the world in a nicer light (because in the end it really isn't that bad) but I find little solace in the idea of coercing people to act 'correctly'.
Will this suffice? *high-five*historybuff said:I want to high-five you.Jedoro said:Yeah, cause I'm a Christian, so I believe that when I die, my soul will go up to heaven, I'll see my loved ones, etc. etc.
I'm just hoping we all get our own little version of heaven. I've always pictured a house for everyone, the size they want it to be, and it has whatever they want inside it. There would be some awesome COD4 tournaments up there, if it were up to me.
Please do.quack35 said:Don't know. I haven't died yet.
I'll get back to you on that...