Poll: Darth Vader vs Voldemort vs Sauron

[Cakes]

Considering Sauron is a minor deity I think it's pretty safe to go with him, unless he's in his weakened form as he was through LoTR. He can't do shit like that. He apparently can't be killed at all though, once the ring is destroyed he's just irreparably weakened.

 

[Hellkite_Overload]

Considering Sauron is a minor deity I think it's pretty safe to go with him, unless he's in his weakened form as he was through LoTR. He can't do shit like that. He apparently can't be killed at all though, once the ring is destroyed he's just irreparably weakened.

This^

well Vader loses automatically since he can be killed no matter how much force power he uses. Plus you would only need to mention padme to him for him to break down. a duel between Voldemort and Sauron would be quite a thing to witness, but I'm betting sauron would ultimately win since he's only a step down from the Valar so he's absurdly powerful. I don't think Voldemort at the peak ofhis power could stand against what is essentially a god.

and this ^

Thank you guys, stated so much better than I could have
and I SOOO wanna see that Sauron/Volemort duel, it would be awesome!

 

[Doitpow]

Sauron has one horcrux, voldemort has 7
it pains me to say I think this one goes to msr. Riddle

 

[goronlink8]

Sauron; a giant, near invincible dude with a suit of working armor and a giant club, massive army, flying demon bird thing riders, a flaming creature with a flaming sword and flaming whip that can fight for days straight.

 

[luckybreak]

That's a good one. At first I was thinking Voldemort because he's immortal but then again as a Sith and as a, whatever the hell Sauron is, you would imagine they might just be able to do something crazy ridiculous like eat souls or something. I have no idea how powerful Sauron is because I have not seen the movies so im just gonna say godlike and hes just weakened for some reason at the moment. So at full power Sauron stands a decent chance. Then again Darth Vader was a jedi, and a ridiculously powerful one at that, Id say he has a pretty good shot at being experienced in dealing with beings like Sauron. Overall, im gonna have to say Vader. I would like to say there is a small chance that Sauron gets both to work for him, with Voldemort becoming his starscreen and Vader just not caring.He does not have any real attachement to palpatine, his reasons for turning evil are gone, he pretty much hates himself, and the only reason he works for Palpatine is cause what else is he gonna do?

 

[KaiusCormere]

Sauron 1v1 -
Strengths - He is a lesser god-being. Thousands of Years of Experience, knowledge
Weaknesses - He put his main power into a ring. He is pretty much running around gimped from that.

Voldemort 1v1 -
Strengths - He is a strong mortal sorceror, but has 7 things you have to break before killing him.
Weaknesses - I don't think he can resist Sauron's mental corruptions. Saruman was thousands of years old master wizard who couldn't.

Vader 1v1 -
Strengths - Better at physical combat.
Weaknesses - Force abilities lack the unlimited range and power of magic. He could probably resist Sauron's mental attacks, and kill Sauron.. I don't know if he could do anything about Voldemort who is not outright slayable to any method Vader has.

Sauron's Army -
Numbers : B - Orcs seem to outnumber anyone else on Middle Earth.
Skill : D - Orcs are not really skilled, almost no orc is a match for a human soldier in a single combat.
Equipment : F - Orcs have shoddy medieval weapons.

Vader's Army -
Numbers : A - Recruiting an army from vat grown clones or recruiting them from a galaxy-spanning empire. Either way, Vader has this on lockdown.
Skill : F - "Only Imperial Stormtroopers are so precise".
Equipment : A - Well, Star Wars level of Technology assures them victory.

Voldemort's Army -
Numbers : F - A sect of rogue mages primarily in England, their numbers can't be more than a few thousand.
Skill : A - They actually know what they are about. Individually, they can threaten main characters.
Equipment : C - Modern and Magical equipment is fairly potent.

Army Battle Conclusions -
Vader will win any war, Voldemort's Army would win any light skirmishing or raiding. Sauron's army would roll over and die.

1v1 Conclusions -
Vader will win against Sauron because Sauron doesn't do overt magic really and Vader has a weapon that can chop off the ring.
Vader will lose against Voldemort because Voldemort generally can't be killed.

Sauron will win against Voldemort because Sauron can't be killed by Voldemort's magic, and can destroy Voldemort's mind with his more dominating mental presence.

 

[Randomperson9999999]

voldomort is invinsible

 

[Auninteligentname]

I will say Voldemort. I haven't read any of the books, but apparently (as stated in this thread), at the peak of his power, he is invinsible. Also, he has avada kadavra, which is insta kill as soon as he point and shouts.

 

[ReaperzXIII]

Voldemort, because at his peak of power he can't be killed. At all.
Lightsaber him if you want, no piece of technology can save you from magic.

Except for the fact magic doesn't work on technology

Last I saw Avada Kedavra was effective against flesshy bits.

Not so effective against bullets are they? But Vader is at a severe disadvantage considering the other two villains in this case are immortal, whilst Vader is very very mortal.

Yeah, but bullets (lasers) are not part of Vader's powers and I was excluding armies for that very purpose.
And even if I didn't, do you really think that the famed markmanship of the Stormtroopers would be enough to take anything down?

Well maybe if the stormtroopers aimed at the sun they would probably hit the other guys, the other times they may just end up killing Vader and their loved ones accidentally.

Also Vader needs to have weapons because that would be like Voldemort without a wand, or Sauron without his ring.

Vader really should not be in this he would be curb stomped since they can only be defeated through magical means.

 

[The87Italians]

I voted Sauron but now that I think about it, Vader. You can't be evil if Vader disintegrated your planet from space.

 

[Radoh]

Well maybe if the stormtroopers aimed at the sun they would probably hit the other guys, the other times they may just end up killing Vader and their loved ones accidentally.

Also Vader needs to have weapons because that would be like Voldemort without a wand, or Sauron without his ring.

Vader really should not be in this he would be curb stomped since they can only be defeated through magical means.

Well yeah, in mine I gave Vader his lightsaber since he always has that and just that, in the same way Voldemort got his wand because he always has that and just that. Also maybe Nagini since he's always there too but that's beside the point.

 

[Bravo 21]

Vader, because the "Force is the ultimate power in the universe" and well, it's awfully hard to use magic when someone is crushing your throat with the force. and sauron, well boom, Deathstar.

 

[Geo Da Sponge]

Well let's see who deafeated each of them:

Voldemort: Killed off by three angsty teenagers on a camping holiday.

Sauron: Finished by a pair of halflings. Fuckin' hobbits, man!

Darth Vader: Killed by the ruler of the galaxy... after he threw him into the core of a moon sized space station.

By the standards of their enemies alone, Darth Vader clearly wins.

 

[Winthrop]

Sauron has one horcrux, voldemort has 7
it pains me to say I think this one goes to msr. Riddle

Not to mention that Sauron has to have his with him all the time. Voldemort would win because even without his wand he could stay alive forever while Vader would dehydrate and Voldemort could simply cut off Sauron's hand at some point. In an army though I'd go Vader for the deathstar.

 

[Hellkite_Overload]

[quote="
Also Vader needs to have weapons because that would be like Voldemort without a wand, or Sauron without his ring.

/quote]

Sauron still has unbelievable amounts of power, even without the ring. The one ring was just a tool he used to control the other races of middle earth through subtle manipulation. To accomplish this, he had to invest a significant amount of his power in the ring, buthe (even on his own, no weapons/armies whatever) he is by no means powerless without it, as the other two are without their tools.

 

[Sigma Van Lockheart]

Vader due the the fact he has the force and a light saber so yea not many problems he cant fix with them and if things get bad he could always run of in a death star.

 

[Mr.Squishy]

Imagine them teaming up to take on their respective adversaries...Fuck you luke, eat killing curse! And Harry, suck on a deity's mace before you can open your little spellcasting mouth. As for Frodo? I can't imagine him dodging the deathstar.

 

[baconsarnie]

With armies Vader wins obviously.
1v1v1 would depend on the battlefield. At anything resembling range voldemort loses due to his spells needing to be on target (assuming he doesn't IMMEDIATELY get his wand robbed by Vader seeing as how the force appears to affect things instantaneously). Regardless of horcruxes being present at the fight voldemorts physical form would get ruined by the others leaving his spirit to wander around for eternity with nothing to do while his horcruxes are found and destroyed.
Sauron beats Vader because, after all he is only human and therefore mortal.

EDIT: of course, i left out the main thing voldemort has in his advantage ... plot holes/people doing things for no reason other than to have knock on effects for the grand finale.

EDIT2: i think we need to answer some basic questions before we start the 1v1v1 fights, 'are they allowed their main weapon (lightsaber, huge-ass mace, stick that has all his power)?', does all of the person need to be present at the fight (no probs for vader, ring of power, horcruxes including main nemesis)?', 'do we apply some game theory and some notion of second place (sauron steps back initially and lets vader steal wand with force power/wait for killing curse to be cast before confronting the other person)?'

 

[snake4769]

Geralt of Rivia would win against any of them, especially voldemort. Cause ya know, killing magic monsters is his thing...