This is actually a fair comparison, unlike Trek Vs. Wars. Unfortunately, I haven't watched enough of any Stargate series to be able to make a fair comparison, although what I have seen puts Star Trek in the lead. For what it's worth, I didn't really discover Stargate until I watched the original film. Unfortunately, I did that during the last season of SG1, which was a really bad point to jump into the series. Long story short, I'm not voting in the poll for this one, because having watched as little Stargate as I have, voting for Star Trek would just make me a fanboy.
[sub]I did really like the Stargate movie -- it was a solid Sci-Fi flick, and I recommend it to any fan of the genre.[/sub]
Edit: I need to stop posting while sleep deprived. This post looks like it was written by the department of redundancies department.