Poll: Half-Life 2 vs. Bioshock Infinite

[shadow_Fox81]

Bioshock infinite, it's just more complex. It's early days but i think infinite will age impeccably

Half life 2 is by contrast a bit of a chore to play through years on and is endearing more as a cultural phenomenon than a title that stands alone.

 

[RedDeadFred]

Bioshock Infinite may not be revolutionary but in order for a game to be revolutionary during these days, the revolution will have to appeal to the masses who just want to shoot things. So using the whole "BI wasn't revolutionary like HL2 was" isn't really fair because they are from different ages of gaming. Likewise, saying BI is better because of it's gameplay and graphics isn't really fair because it has way better technology. Judging both from their stories I think is really the only way to compare them and IMO, BI beats HL2 here by a longshot.

Anyway, sorry to necro this thread. I just beat BI and decided I'd go and search for people's thoughts on the ending and I ended up stumbling upon this thread.

 

[Guy from the 80's]

I did enjoy Infinite, but the standard fight-your-way-to-a-bad guy-that-speaks-via-your-radio-device-through-out-the-entire-game is getting old. I really wish Bioware would come up with something new. And Comstock? What a boring character.

Why not make a Bioshock game where there are no ultimate villain like Ryan-Comstock? Why not make a game where the plot is different.

 

[Extra-Ordinary]

This is going to end well...
My vote went to Bioshock.
Half-Life is great, no doubt about that, but personally, I couldn't get into it.
Bioshock Infinite on the other hand...