Poll: LARPS or table top

Recommended Videos

deathninja

New member
Dec 19, 2008
745
0
0
Never really got into LRP, mainly because it's too easy for egomaniacs to try and commandeer the plot (c.f. Camarilla).

Instead I go for MilSim airsoft weekenders, light RP, shooting stuff and tanks, what's not to love?
 

samsprinkle

New member
Jun 29, 2008
1,091
0
0
Table top is better I think. It leaves more to the imagination. I would like to do the thing where you reinact battles in armor though...
 

Aries_Split

New member
May 12, 2008
2,097
0
0
rossatdi said:
LARPs is the bottom end of the barrel. I play table top RPGs and we rip into the LARPs people.

I mean there's being a nerd, and then there's LARPs.
That makes you shallow.While you pretend to be a midi evil warrior in a dark flat whilst drinking beer and rolling dice, you look down on others who go out into a large forest, drink beer, and beat the shit out of eachother in something called the SUN, WHILST pretending to be a midi evil warrior.


Huh, when you put into perspective, it's a lot less easy to call said person a nerd.

Pot, kettle, kettle, pot.
 

vede

New member
Dec 4, 2007
859
0
0
I prefer tabletop, not-getting-my-head-bludgeoned-to-a-pulp, hearty fun.

HOWEVER, LARPs could be cool, in a certain circumstance. That circumstance is: an entire town is in on it. That could be really cool, especially if there was a designated group of people meant to start up strange stories and events to make it interesting. Also, if multiple towns were in on it, and they were "at war," and the towns realistically acted like they were at war (but without the killing). Like, if people got called out to fight.

That would be totally awesome. If someone were to set that up to run for, say, a month, I'd be in. I'd probably just be a peasant trying to flee from invasion, though. Or a spy.

Anything smaller scale than that, not cool. Go tabletop for things involving less than a hundred people or so.

EDIT: Oh yeah, new button images = obnoxious looking. No likey.
 

Silver

New member
Jun 17, 2008
1,142
0
0
I really hate it when these threads come up. The LARP culture is so different in different countries, we have the overly, almost sickeningly nerdy stuff in America, that just feels embarrasing to even mention (no offence), we have the German LARPs that consists of lots and lots and lots and lots and lots of people dressing up as Warhammer characters and beating the crap out of each other. We have the almost sad UK LARPs where there are GM's running around and people have character sheets and stuff. We have the Russian variety that's almost indistinguishable from Reenactment.

And then we have the Swedish and Norwegian version I'm very partial to myself, that's trying to create the illusion of another world. More than any of the other types, it's about the role you're playing. It's closer to improvisational theatre than tabletop roleplaying. Sure, I know it sounds pretentious and stuff, but whatever, I'm biased.

I always feel that we should make up another term for it, since it's so very far away from each other. While in Germany, the UK and America (in general), the focus lies as much on the stats part, while in Scandinavia, the focus lies on breathing life into the fictional world. You don't go out of character, you don't go there to bash people with weapons.

Think of it like being in a movie, but throwing out the main characters. Take Mad Max, think about being one of the people in the village, or in LotR, and you're just a regular Joe in Minas Tirith.

I'm trying to find some videos on Youtube or something to illustrate what I mean, but the only two documentaries I've found are in Swedish, and the visuals don't really show much. Other than that there's just a lot of people messing around.

These are kind of neat, from a post-apocalyptic LARP:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F47shP5ZBVs&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGnphN8QgkI&feature=related


But it still doesn't show much, sadly.
 

shatnershaman

New member
May 8, 2008
2,627
0
0
LARPS. I do play table top gaming and while it is nerdy at least you can justify it by saying its a grittier chess. LARPS would only pass of as a terrible play. About LOTR. With 5'8 hobbits.
 

Silver

New member
Jun 17, 2008
1,142
0
0
shatnershaman said:
LARPS. I do play table top gaming and while it is nerdy at least you can justify it by saying its a grittier chess. LARPS would only pass of as a terrible play. About LOTR. With 5'8 hobbits.
Yeah... But in the LARP you've got hot girls dressed up as vampires. There's nothing nerdy about hot girl dressed up as vampires.
 

shatnershaman

New member
May 8, 2008
2,627
0
0
Silver said:
shatnershaman said:
LARPS. I do play table top gaming and while it is nerdy at least you can justify it by saying its a grittier chess. LARPS would only pass of as a terrible play. About LOTR. With 5'8 hobbits.
Yeah... But in the LARP you've got hot girls dressed up as vampires. There's nothing nerdy about hot girl dressed up as vampires.
No vampire girls in the LARPS I've seen. Just 6 foot Frodo.
 

Anstrup

New member
Dec 8, 2008
121
0
0
Earlier i made a bold claim that LARPs could be as story based as tabletops, and i promised to specify.

Basically we have like three types of LARP (please note that theese are personal terms used by me and my freinds, who also LARP):

The first and most common kind is hack 'n' slash. Theese are basically twatathons in silly outfits, poorly made outfits.

The second are what we call crack scenarios, theese are alot about the combat, but also about the characters and the story. The stories are often made, so that it is possible to have alot of laughs. Alot of them focus on stereotypes, since they are pretty easy to improvise. This kind of LARP are pretty common as well, but the age limit is usually higher than the hck n slash kind.

The last are what me and my mates call hardcore or deep larping. Theese are for the educated actors, where the players have to dig deep into their own personalities. The budgets for theese are usually extensive, involving workshops to create both character and costumes/other types of equipment

But all of theese use one of two story models.
The first is what we call the star or the cog. Theese use faction based stories, where each faction is point of the star, and story comes from the innteraction in between, hack n slash are all based on this model, and alot of the crack scenarios are as well. The only real story here, is the background story.

The second is the railroad, this one uses scripted events (the railroad) to tell a story, and then at each station, the players gets to interact with the story, perhaps change it. But bascially the scripted drives the story, BUT the palyers interact, and can change the story, the good railroad larp, has alot of scripted events, that are possible to use, if the player pushes the story in the either direction.

What i am trying to say is, that larps tend to differ alot in story telling, and story telling is just as possible in larping as in table topping. But alot of it, well all of it depends on the planning and modelling of the scenarios at hand. Yeah it can be a violent team sport, but it can storytelling as well.
 

axia777

New member
Oct 10, 2008
2,895
0
0
LARPS is lame. Don't fool yourself. Even the name "LARPS" sounds lame. You don't need an excuse to beat each other senseless with padded weapons. Me and my buddies do it all the time. We just don't dress up and pretend that we are Elves and shit. That is lame.
 

Jaythulhu

New member
Jun 19, 2008
1,745
0
0
After attending one session of the local "camarilla" larp group, I gotta say that if i ever get back in to rpg'ing, it's gonna be table top all the way. Such sad, pathetic losers doing larp around here, though I guess that's a side-effect of being a surf/beachbum state. All said and told, ruining a camarilla group meeting by copying a KotD sketch was one of the most fun nights I've had.
 

Boris_the_beast

New member
Dec 24, 2008
3
0
0
I love tabletop gaming but I have to say LARP is more fun.....on 1 condition.....its a decent LARP. I've seen plenty of extremely nerdy LARP vids on youtube, some of them just make me want to curl up into a ball and rock back and forth until its over. The magic only happens if you get the right people, setting, skills and costumes.

This is the best LARP I've been to:

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=nQqOYCnfvUY
 

deathninja

New member
Dec 19, 2008
745
0
0
Jaythulhu said:
After attending one session of the local "camarilla" larp group, I gotta say that if i ever get back in to rpg'ing, it's gonna be table top all the way. Such sad, pathetic losers doing larp around here, though I guess that's a side-effect of being a surf/beachbum state. All said and told, ruining a camarilla group meeting by copying a KotD sketch was one of the most fun nights I've had.
Ah, Mind's Eye Theatre

It is shit, mainly because the longest playing characters have so much clout, and without exception get arsey if not everything in the region goes their way.

I only stuck it out so long because there were a bunch of us who kept derailing everything (though that used to be so much easier when they had Malkavians)
 

pantsoffdanceoff

New member
Jun 14, 2008
2,751
0
0
I used to be quite the D&D player back in my day. Yessiree they would call me Johnny d20. LARP isn't really all that great though, sure once in a while a like to take a baseball bat smack my friend across the face call him a dirty koboooold and how blame LARP and not me.