Crayzor said:
eggy32 said:
This doesn't make any sense. Wouldn't masturbation have the same result? You know, since the body can't really tell the difference.
This. It's a stupid idea and I can't believe anyone would ever take it seriously.
Well, if you check the original thread, this idea started a chain of events which culminated in three convicted rapists being released from prison...
Hyzenthlay said:
Does this theory apply to women as well or only men?
Men only, as far as I can work out. The previous theory (prior to the invention of 'magic dot theory') was that you could tell whether or not a man was a virgin by taking his pulse. I suppose that must work for women too, using the inventors somewhat ludicrous definition of the word "work".
eggy32 said:
This doesn't make any sense. Wouldn't masturbation have the same result? You know, since the body can't really tell the difference.
No. Neither masturbation nor gay sex have any effect on the red dot. Only heterosexual sex makes it disappear, but there is no confirmation of whether that is restricted to vaginal penetration, or whether it includes anal and oral sex with a female. Besides, these dudes had been in prison for a decade by the time she tested - it'd pretty much
have to be impervious to wanking (not to mention any "relationships" they maye have formed in prison!)
Czargent Sane said:
JinxyKatte said:
Really?? Are we really going to do this? Its the single most ludicrous thing I have ever heard. Seriously it ranks up their with Intelligent Design.
wait, thinking your skin changes when you have sex is as ludicrous as believing in the theory of evolution and also in God?
Don't ID proponents claim (in an attempt to legitimze it as science, I guess) that their theory only invokes a "higher being" as a creator rather than any specific deity or creation myth? It never really works in practice, of course, since most of the major ID guys are Christians attempting to pass off Creationism by making it look more scientific, but on paper ID is supposedly non-religious. I wasn't aware IDers (at least mainstream ones) believed in evolution either; the clue is in the word "design".