Poll: "They just hate it because it's popular."

Recommended Videos

Your once and future Fanboy

The Norwegian One
Feb 11, 2009
572
0
0
I dont automaticly hate something because its popular, but i am usually more judgemental or exspect more from it.
I believe that it should be popular based on merit and/or on quality, therefore I like games like Final Fantasy 7 or Call of Duty 4 : modern warfare, while I dont like Halo or Madden.
 

Ilikemilkshake

New member
Jun 7, 2010
1,975
0
0
Thundero13 said:
Ilikemilkshake said:
Yup, Twilight i hated for.. well at least a year for precisely that reason, then i decided i would stop being a hypocrite cos im always saying you should form your own opinion on things, so i watched all 3 twilight movies.

After watching i can safely say i still dont like twilight.. but at least im not a hypocrite.
Aren't there four Twilight movies?
There's 4 books but only 3 movies so far, next is coming out next year (i think)
yay.
 

Xanadu84

New member
Apr 9, 2008
2,946
0
0
I don't think so. Sometimes ive been too lofty minded to really appreciate something that runs on mass appeal, but as a general rule, I recover and see the strength of most popular things. And if I don't like something popular, I at least acknowledge that it must be doing something right and wonder what that is, whether I see it or not.
 

C2Ultima

Future sovereign of Oz
Nov 6, 2010
506
0
0
No, I haven't. Whatever I encounter, I judge on it's own merits. A lot of the time, things that are popular are popular because they're good, like Avatar or Harry Potter. Sometimes there are some flukes with this system. Bad things are hugely popular (Transformers Films, Twilight), and sometimes good things aren't successful (Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World).
 

theLadyBugg

New member
May 24, 2010
88
0
0
Yes --- case in point, Justin Beiber. I've never heard him sing, seen a music video, whatever. But I know that I'm not interested in hearing him sing, and seeing/hearing him mentioned everywhere gets me pretty seriously irritated.

I don't think it's hypocritical, here's why: A thing I could've easily lived my life without ever knowing about is now regularly invading my space because it is popular, and the only ones to blame for that are the people who made it popular -- ie Beiber and his parents, manager, publicist, producer, etc. They crafted a thing to appeal to a large and noisy audience.

Do I hate the "brand" that is Justin Beiber? Yes. How did I come to hate it? Rampant popularity forced me to acknowledge it. Ergo, I hate JB because it is popular.
 

Semitendon

New member
Aug 4, 2009
359
0
0
I voted yes.

But, that is because I have one, and only one, instance of hating something because so many other people like it.

Fuck the New York Yankees.

I don't like baseball much anyway, but a few years back, it seemed I was running into guys who loved the team, and girls who loved that asshole Derek Jeter, constantly.

I am a fan of the Boston Red Sox now ( for those that don't know, the Red Sox are the Yankees sworn enemies)

Other than that, everything I've ever hated came with an at least somewhat valid reason.
 

DustyDrB

Made of ticky tacky
Jan 19, 2010
8,361
3
43
Eh. I don't buy the "hate it because its popular" idea. People will hate it for some other reason and the fact that it becomes popular means that whatever annoys them is magnified.

"You just hate it because it's popular" is nothing but a cop-out argument issued by people who can't fathom that other people may actually think differently.
 

Goldenkitten01

New member
Aug 23, 2010
43
0
0
Probably the closest I ever came was FF13. I heard all the stuff about how it pretty much had everything that made an RPG an RPG ripped out of it and went into the game expecting to hate it. Thankfully I DID hate it so I feel a little bit better about making presumptions but still I try to avoid this sort of thing. Other than that one example I can't think of many cases, I'm sure my perception has been swayed before but that's the only one I can think of where that sort of fits, and even then my hate was more based on opinions of what the game could be and not just because it was popular (for no good reason).
 

Fooz

New member
Oct 22, 2010
1,054
0
0
well i always thought LOTR seemed kind of shitty, but i actually watched the 1st one yesterday and its quite good, watching the second this weekend
 

Thundero13

New member
Mar 19, 2009
2,392
0
0
Ilikemilkshake said:
Thundero13 said:
Ilikemilkshake said:
Yup, Twilight i hated for.. well at least a year for precisely that reason, then i decided i would stop being a hypocrite cos im always saying you should form your own opinion on things, so i watched all 3 twilight movies.

After watching i can safely say i still dont like twilight.. but at least im not a hypocrite.
Aren't there four Twilight movies?
There's 4 books but only 3 movies so far, next is coming out next year (i think)
yay.
*Oh Joy she's not finished making them*, i've seen the first film and I think that's enough of it to hate Twilight without being a hypocrite...
 

liquidsolid

New member
Feb 18, 2011
357
0
0
At some points, I hear music or see a movie that I think is alright, but the fact that everyone seems to LOVE it makes me dislike it. I feel like it is not worthy of the praise it gets. Examples: LIl Wayne, World of Warcraft, and Avatar.
 

The Lunatic

Princess
Jun 3, 2010
2,291
0
0
Not really.

I tend to be a bit cautious of popular things when trying them, I tend to hold the opinion the what the majority of people want in a game, movie, TV series or whatever isn't what I want in a game or whatever.

Popular things are perfectly capable of being good, it's just, most don't appeal to me. I'd much rather play an old school RPG than a fresh new shooter, it's just my tastes and interests.
 

Zabriskie Point

New member
Nov 22, 2010
109
0
0
I'm more annoyed by people who say that everyone who hates call of duty is a hipster than the hipsters who hate call of duty because it's popular.

Call of Duty isn't the greatest game ever made. There are good reasons to hate it, but there are also bad reasons to hate it.
 

AssassinJoe

New member
Oct 1, 2010
625
0
0
The whole Final Fantasy series.

Not just because it's popular though. I just don't get the whole premise, and the fact that it's such a popular series makes me hate it even more.
 

moretwocents

New member
Jan 20, 2011
75
0
0
Yes. All the way.
Justin Bieber has an UNGODLY huge fan base and the voice of a five year old girl.
What do these people see in him? He sings pop songs, so what? Lady Gaga does that while her bra lights on fire after coming out of a giant egg. Tell me that's not at least more interesting than Bieber.
Yes, I hate him just for his fanbase, so rabid and vile it makes me want to puke.
 

Squallie Greenthumb

New member
May 16, 2011
37
0
0
tigermilk said:
Anyone else think the poll should jsut have two options 'yes' and 'don't lie'?
No. If we all hated everything that was popular we would've stopped using the internet once everybody got it and more importantly would've hated video games once the captain of the Football team bought an xbox. That's something you should probably mention the next time you're in the situation that this thread started off with.

Also people who actually do hate stuff just because it's popular probably liked it before it got popular and now feels robbed of it. This is something that needs to change. Recently I got into a discussion where someone thought I hated zombies now just because they're everywhere and I've been a horror fan since I could breathe so I liked it first. Dawn of the Dead hasn't gotten worse because a girl with a Louis Vuitton bag who watches Jersey Shore likes it now, but since it's become popular there is now a case of horrible oversaturation and the meaning of Zombies has been destroyed. But this will pass. Same thing happens with music, sports teams, movies and pretty much anything else.

What's important to remember is that for you it's what you love, for them it's a fad. Eventually they'll leave it all behind and you'll be there to clean up after them and pick up your drunken, puking, mess of an interest and take it home to nurse back to health and spend its life with you again.
 

Jandau

Smug Platypus
Dec 19, 2008
5,030
0
0
No, I have not. I have hated (well, disliked is more accurate, I rarely hate) some things that also happened to be popular. But I dislike those things entirely on their own merit.

For instance, I think Modern Warfare 2 is a bad game because the only part of it I'm interested in (single player) is poorly paced, spastic and plays out like a fevered dream of a 10-year old with ADD. I also dislike Oblivion because of the nonexistant plot, zero noteworthy characters, backwards retarded game mechanics and a bland boring world that simply isn't worth exploring.

Very rarely do I dislike something based on word of mouth and second-hand evidence, but this is usually due to a unanimous vote by pretty much everyone else. For instance, I've never touched Kane&Lynch:Dog Days, but I'm fairly certain it's a steaming pile of poop. Granted, that game isn't very popular, but the principle stands. I don't need to watch Jersey Shore to know I'd hate it.

In most cases though, I tend to see for myself. I rented Twilight and sat through it to make sure it's bad. It was. I borrowed my friend's copy of Crysis to confirm that it's a boring FPS with overproduced graphics done by an engine wasted on rendering grass.

But I hate it when people accuse me of disliking things because they're popular - I like or dislike stuff and don't care if it's popular.

EDIT: However, there is a simple reason why popular things get hated. They get more spotlight, more people get to hear about them and get to form opinions based on whatever info they find.
 

144_v1legacy

New member
Apr 25, 2008
648
0
0
Who here saw Yahtzee Portal 2 critique? Portal 1 was something he liked, which then became sullied by the others who shared his opinion. It's completely reasonable, and anyone who hasn't felt this way or similar, intentionally or not, is certainly not someone who posts on the escapist.