MelasZepheos said:
I don't get why Portal needed a sequel. I know I may be in a minority with this opinion but I really don't get what the second game is really going to add apart from diverting Valve's attention (and thus their fanboys' attention) from that whole Half Life 3 thing they were supposed to be working on.
Portal was brilliant, no argument here, but it was a self-contained series of clever portal based puzzles which had the gameplay ideas to last about four hours and only tried to last four hours.
Portal 2 strikes me as the moment Valve are going to become more interested in money than fanbase, if Left 4 Dead 2 hadn't already shown that.
1) Just because it doesn't need a sequel doesn't mean they shouldn't give it a try; in my opinion a series should continue until it runs out of good ideas. The Spiderman movie didn't need a sequel but Spiderman 2 was a big hit and not everyone hated Spiderman 3.
2) The sequel will introduce several new gameplay elements opening up more opportunities for new puzzles, THAT'S what the second game is going to add and while I'm on the subject,
3) New gameplay mechanics could make the game last longer without overstaying it's welcome. With the new kind of mechanics they introduce the sequel could last as long as a full price game without overstaying it's welcome.
4) It sounds a lot like you think this game will be nothing more than a cheap cash grab. Don't you think that opinion is best saved until AFTER the game comes out?
5) ValVe has ALWAYS been interested in money more than fanbase because the fanbase is their primary source of money. If they were more interested in fanbase than money they probably would've gone broke by now.
6) As I stated earlier, ValVe makes most of it's money off of it's fanbase and is so successful because it tends to give it's fanbase what it wants or what it thinks will please them. Why change a formula that essentially MADE them the video game titan they are today?
7) I know this is personal opinion but as much as I like Half Life, Episode 3 can wait if it means a sequel to a game like Portal.
8) ValVe has tried to make good on it's promise to the L4D fans with Crash Course and The Sacrifice as well as giving L4D2 The Passing AND the Mutations and even then,
9) L4D2 SHOULD have been made. Why? Because not everyone has the requirements to get Xbox Live and in most cases a full game is more satisfying than ANY amount of DLC; You'll often play a full game consistently until you beat it while with DLC you'll play it for maybe a day or two before saying "well enough of that. Time to check the New Release list".